Mass Theater Review: A Masterful Exploration of Forgiveness After School Shooting Tragedy

The Aftermath of Tragedy: A Powerful Theatrical Encounter

Fran Kranz's 2021 film Mass, featuring two sets of parents whose sons have died in a high-school massacre, was originally written as a play. Restored as such, in Carrie Cracknell's production, it takes place in the backroom of a church where their across-the-table encounter encapsulates a pained instance of restorative justice.

Character Portrayals: Navigating Complex Emotions

Gail (Lyndsey Marshal) and Jay (Adeel Akhtar) are the parents of Evan, one of 10 children murdered by the teenage shooter, Hayden, the son of Richard (Paul Hilton) and Linda (Monica Dolan), who then killed himself. Evan's parents want to understand why Hayden committed such violence but there is also an unspoken sense of blame buzzing around them. Hayden's parents address this first: we blame ourselves, they say, again and again, yet in one dangerous moment, they posit the notion of separating who their son was, and what he did.

Stage Design and Emotional Impact

The stark, unflinching treatment of this subject matter is well realised on Anna Yates's set, where two office-style storeys stretch across the stage, and it does not sugarcoat the emotionally messy nature of the process. Both sides are explored. One terrible instance of maternal anguish comes from Linda when she speaks about a threatening memory of her son and for this charged moment, the play enters the emotional territory of Lionel Shriver's We Need To Talk About Kevin.

Performances: A Masterclass in Emotional Depth

It is hard to beat the force and sensitive performances of Kranz's film but Hilton is masterfully brittle, his entire being sunken with apology, while Dolan is whey-faced and shaky. The always brilliant Akhtar is angrier and edgier than his film counterpart and Marshal brings a moving softness.

Theatrical vs. Cinematic Experience

Like the film, it takes time to build in intensity, with the awkward arrangements of the opening and the small talk. There is not the same reflective space of the film, which pulls away from the claustobia and pain in the room at key moments. Here, there is no looking away.

Forgiveness and Polarization: Dual Themes

The play works on two levels: as a drama of forgiveness and of polarisation. What would happen if any of us sat down with those at the furthest ideological extreme from our own, however unpalatable their views? Listening is the pathway towards empathy for these characters, even if there is desire for vengeance or vindication along the way. By the end, they are all parents who have lost sons, grieving over this tragedy in different ways.

Where to Experience This Powerful Production

At Donmar Warehouse, London, until 6 June