UK's Higher-Earning Immigrants Face Deterrence Under New Settlement Rules

The Lead

Higher-earning immigrants are less likely to remain in the UK long-term and could be further deterred from staying by the government's planned crackdown on settlement rights, analysis has revealed.

Key Findings on Migration Patterns

A report from the Migration Advisory Committee's "Who Stays, Who Leaves?" follows about 900,000 journeys between 2014 and 2024. The research is intended to help understanding of long-term migration patterns and the possible effects of policy changes on labour shortages, population forecasts and the public finances.

Income-Based Migration Trends

The MAC report states: "Our analysis suggests migrants earning the lowest wages are the most likely to remain in the UK long term, while there is some evidence that those with the highest salaries (£125,000+) are the most likely income group to leave. These [higher-paid] migrants may benefit from more global opportunities and lower financial barriers to moving elsewhere, reducing the incentives to remain in the UK longer-term."

Proposed Policy Changes

Shabana Mahmood, the home secretary, proposes raising the baseline qualifying period for settled status in the UK from five years to 10. The proposals say those who meet certain criteria, including higher-rate taxpayers, could qualify for discounts that would reduce the wait for indefinite leave to remain back down to five years. However, MAC's report warns that stricter rules could discourage higher earners from remaining in Britain.

Demographic and Regional Variations

The analysis found the UK is retaining younger migrants. Those aged under 45 had an 81% five-year stay rate, compared with 65% for those aged 45 or over. Meanwhile, immigrants earning under £40,000 and health and social care workers demonstrated a "high commitment to remain", with 94% of nurses staying after five years. The lowest stay rates were among "natural and social science professionals" – predominantly academics – only 57% of whom remained after five years.

Geographic and Sectoral Differences

People from African and South Asian countries had the highest stay rates, and people from North America, Oceania, and east Asia had the lowest. London was the region most likely to retain migrants, while Scotland and Wales recorded the lowest stay rates. Although standalone figures were not provided, women were about five percentage points more likely to remain after five years than men, in part reflecting that women are more likely to work in health and social care.

Economic and Fiscal Implications

Beyond individual tax contributions made by lower-paid immigrants, the report said there were "broad societal impacts", such as the "wider fiscal impacts of a well-functioning care sector" to consider. The fact that younger workers are more likely to stay than older workers pushes the fiscal contribution upwards, since younger workers have more of their working, tax-paying lives ahead of them.

Future Outlook for UK Immigration Policy

The report warns that groups with lower stay rates under the current policy – such as higher earners and people working in higher education – could be more susceptible to being deterred by a less generous settlement offer. This could potentially lead to significant shifts in the UK's immigration landscape, affecting labor markets, public finances, and the composition of the UK's long-term resident population.