Caro Claire Burke's 'Yesteryear' Falls Short: A Missed Opportunity to Explore the Dark Side of Tradwife Culture

Caro Claire Burke's Yesteryear had all the makings of a thought-provoking novel: a tradwife protagonist who wakes up in the pioneer days and finds that traditional wifedom is not as glamorous as her social media persona had suggested. The premise is genius, and the protagonist Natalie's biting and occasionally hilarious voice makes the novel zip along.

However, as the story progresses, it becomes clear that Burke has failed to create a convincing mother figure in Natalie, and the novel's exploration of pronatalism and traditional Christian values feels shallow and cliched. The author's decision to remove politics almost entirely from the narrative is also a major omission, particularly given the current cultural climate.

The novel's main drive becomes resolving the mystery of Natalie's situation - has she really time travelled, or is this an awful reality TV show? - to the detriment of more profound concerns. Burke's treatment of birth injury and child disability as a plot point is also shockingly cack-handed and feels cynical and underresearched.

Overall, Yesteryear is a disappointing novel that fails to live up to its promise. Despite its talented author, the book feels like a lesson in not allowing a fun premise to get in the way of a good story.