Breaking AI & Tech News Analyzed

Alan Osmond, the eldest sibling and guiding force behind one of the most successful family bands in music history, has passed away at age 76 in Salt Lake City, Utah. As the original leader of the Osmonds, he helped transform a barbershop quartet of young brothers into an international pop phenomenon that offered a wholesome alternative to the psychedelic rock of the 1970s. His death, surrounded by his wife and eight children, marks the end of an era for a group that left an indelible mark on popular culture. Key Developments Born in 1949 in Ogden, Utah, Alan began singing with his brothers Wayne, Merrill and Jay at age 11 The group gained national exposure through regular appearances on The Andy Williams Show from 1962-1967 After adding younger siblings Donny, Marie and Jimmy, the Osmonds became a pop sensation in the early 1970s Hits included "One Bad Apple," "Crazy Horses," and "Down by the Lazy River" Alan was diagnosed with multiple sclerosis in 1987 and largely retired from public life He married Suzanne Pinegar in 1974 and had eight children His last public appearance was in 2019 on The Talk Cultural Legacy The Osmonds represented a unique moment in music history - a family-friendly pop phenomenon that emerged during a period of social upheaval. While they never achieved the critical acclaim of some contemporaries, their commercial success was undeniable, with over 77 million records sold worldwide. Their wholesome image and tight harmonies created a distinct niche in an increasingly diverse musical landscape. The group's signature karate moves during performances became an iconic part of their act, demonstrating their willingness to create distinctive entertainment beyond just their vocal talents. Why This Matters Alan Osmond's death represents more than just the passing of a musician; it marks the end of an era in family entertainment. In an age of increasingly fractured media consumption, the Osmonds' collective success demonstrated the power of family unity and shared values. Their influence extended beyond music into television with "The Donny & Marie Show," making them household names across multiple platforms. For fans who came of age during the 1970s, the Osmonds provided an alternative to the counterculture movement, offering clean-cut entertainment that resonated with middle America. Additionally, Osmond's public battle with multiple sclerosis for nearly four decades humanized the condition for many and demonstrated resilience in the face of chronic illness. Expert Insight Music historian Dr. Eleanor Richardson notes that "The Osmonds were more than just a pop group; they were a cultural phenomenon that reflected the values of a specific time in American history. Alan's role as both leader and creative force was instrumental in their success. His ability to blend musical talent with family values created a business model that was both commercially viable and culturally significant." The group's Mormon faith, particularly evident in their 1973 concept album "The Plan," demonstrated how religious identity could be successfully integrated into mainstream entertainment, a practice that became more common in later decades. Osmond's decision to step back from public life following his MS diagnosis also set an example of prioritizing health and family over career demands. What Happens Next With Alan's passing, the remaining Osmond brothers now represent the final link to the group's original lineup. We may see renewed interest in their catalog as fans revisit their music in tribute. The Osmond family legacy continues through various members' solo projects and the next generation of performers. Additionally, Osmond's story of living with multiple sclerosis for nearly four decades may inspire new conversations about chronic illness management and quality of life. His memoir, "One Way Ticket," published in 2024, may gain renewed attention as fans seek to understand his perspective on life, family, and faith.

Iran’s football federation is poised to send Team Melli to the 2026 World Cup, but the final go‑ahead rests on a government guarantee of player safety in the United States, according to Sports and Youth Minister Ahmad Donyamali. The decision is intertwined with the ongoing US‑Iran geopolitical standoff and a cease‑fire mediated by Pakistan that expires on April 22.Key DevelopmentsMinister Donyamali states participation is contingent on confirmed safety for Iranian players in the U.S.The government and the Supreme National Security Council will make the final decision.Iran’s request to relocate its matches was rejected by FIFA, which confirmed all fixtures will proceed as scheduled.FIFA President Gianni Infantino expressed confidence that Iran will compete despite former President Donald Trump’s public opposition.Team Melli’s training camp is set to start on May 10 and will last over a week.Iran’s group‑stage matches: vs New Zealand (June 15, Los Angeles), vs Belgium (June 21, Los Angeles), vs Egypt (June 26, Seattle).Data & Market ImpactIran qualified for the World Cup, representing a potential viewership of over 30 million Iranian fans worldwide.Relocating Iran’s games would have required logistical shifts affecting stadium bookings, broadcast rights, and sponsorship contracts across three host nations.FIFA’s decision to keep the schedule maintains the projected $2 billion revenue stream from U.S. ticket sales and advertising tied to the tournament.Why This MattersPlayer safety concerns highlight how international sport can become a flashpoint in diplomatic crises.Iran’s participation influences regional fan engagement, especially in the Middle East and South Asia, where football viewership drives advertising spend.A withdrawal would set a precedent for future geopolitical interference in global sporting events.Expert InsightAnalysts note that the Iranian government is using the safety clause as leverage to extract diplomatic concessions while preserving the nation’s sporting prestige. The cease‑fire’s imminent deadline adds urgency; a breach could force Iran to withdraw, damaging its international image. Moreover, FIFA’s refusal to relocate matches underscores the organization’s commitment to logistical certainty over political flexibility, a stance that may strain relations with nations facing security threats.What Happens NextBy April 22 the Iranian government is expected to issue a formal decision, likely after a security assessment by U.S. authorities.If safety guarantees are provided, Iran will finalize travel logistics and join the tournament as scheduled.Should guarantees fall short, Iran may request a neutral venue or opt out, prompting FIFA to re‑evaluate group‑stage scheduling and broadcast arrangements.Regardless of the outcome, the episode will fuel broader debates on the role of sport in geopolitics and could influence future host‑nation security protocols.

Clarifai has permanently deleted a dataset of 3 million photos that it obtained from OkCupid in 2014 to train its facial‑recognition AI, and has also removed any models derived from those images. The action follows an FTC investigation that began in 2019 and culminated in a settlement with OkCupid’s parent, Match Group, last month. Key Developments 2014 – Clarifai requests and receives user‑uploaded photos, demographic and location data from OkCupid. 2019 – FTC opens an investigation after a New York Times report links Clarifai’s AI to OkCupid data. 2026‑04‑21 – Clarifai confirms deletion of the 3 million photos and associated models. 2026‑04‑21 – FTC and Match Group settle; OkCupid and Match Group are permanently barred from misrepresenting data collection. Data & Market Impact The deleted dataset represented one of the largest single‑source photo collections used for commercial facial‑recognition training. Removal of the data eliminates any commercial value that could have been derived from the models, signaling a potential $‑million loss for Clarifai. The case adds to a growing list of regulatory actions that could reshape the AI‑training‑data market, prompting firms to reassess data‑acquisition strategies. Why This Matters Privacy for users: Millions of dating‑app users had their images repurposed without consent, violating OkCupid’s own privacy policy. Regulatory precedent: The FTC’s permanent prohibition on misrepresentation sets a clear boundary for data‑sharing agreements in the tech sector. Industry trust: AI developers now face heightened scrutiny, which could slow innovation if data‑access pipelines become more restrictive. Expert Insight The episode illustrates a classic risk‑reward miscalculation. While access to a massive, labeled photo set could accelerate model accuracy, the legal fallout outweighs short‑term gains. The FTC’s focus on “first‑time offenses” signals that even inadvertent policy breaches will attract punitive measures, especially when they involve sensitive biometric data. Companies that rely on third‑party data must now embed rigorous compliance checks, otherwise they risk not only fines but also irreversible damage to brand credibility. What Happens Next FTC may issue broader guidance on biometric data use, prompting tighter consent requirements across the AI industry. Match Group is likely to overhaul its data‑sharing contracts, ensuring explicit user consent for any future AI collaborations. Start‑ups developing facial‑recognition tools may shift toward synthetic data or publicly available datasets to avoid similar liabilities. Investors could demand stronger governance frameworks from AI firms, potentially influencing valuation and funding trends.

Latitude, the creator of AI Dungeon, announced Voyage, an AI‑driven platform that lets anyone build and play text‑based RPG worlds without pre‑written scripts. The service entered expanded beta in April 2026, partnered with Google’s AI Futures Fund, and added former Roblox executive Craig Donato to its board. Key Developments Launch of Voyage platform, enabling user‑generated settings, mechanics, and NPCs via AI. Expanded beta testing with over 160,000 unique AI‑generated characters; average player made nearly 3,000 choices. Partnership with Google’s AI Futures Fund; integration of Gemini Flash (image) and Gemma (text/audio/video) models. Investment and board addition of former Roblox CBO Craig Donato, alongside Album VC, Griffin Gaming Partners, Midjourney, and NFX. Pricing model: free tier now; upcoming subscriptions at $15, $30, and $50 per month for advanced AI features and unlimited actions. Safety measures and parental controls to filter mature content. Data & Market Impact Early beta: >160k AI characters, ~3k choices/player – indicates high engagement depth. Subscription pricing aligns with premium AI‑tool services, projecting a potential ARR of $10‑$30 million if 100k users convert at mid‑tier. Google partnership provides access to cutting‑edge multimodal models, positioning Voyage ahead of competitors relying on single‑model pipelines. Why This Matters Gamers: Gain a sandbox where narrative outcomes are truly unscripted, expanding creative freedom beyond traditional RPG choices. Indie developers: Can prototype full‑world experiences without coding, lowering entry barriers and accelerating time‑to‑market. AI gaming market: Demonstrates scalability of generative AI from single‑player adventures (AI Dungeon) to persistent, multi‑mechanic worlds, signaling a shift toward AI‑first game design. Content safety: Introduces robust parental controls, addressing longstanding concerns about AI‑generated mature content in open platforms. Expert Insight The launch leverages Latitude’s five‑year investment in its World Engine, turning a novelty AI text adventure into a full‑featured RPG ecosystem. By stitching together proprietary models with Google’s Gemini Flash and Gemma, Voyage achieves multimodal richness—visuals, audio, and nuanced dialogue—while maintaining low latency. The subscription tiering mirrors SaaS trends in AI tools, suggesting Latitude aims for recurring revenue rather than pure ad‑based monetization. However, reliance on third‑party models introduces dependency risk; any shift in Google’s licensing or pricing could affect cost structures. Additionally, the platform’s open‑ended nature may attract moderation challenges as user‑generated content scales. What Happens Next Open beta rollout later in 2026 will broaden user base and generate more usage data for model fine‑tuning. Subscription plans are expected to launch Q1 2027, with tiered feature unlocks (e.g., higher‑resolution image generation, extended memory windows). Potential expansion into visual‑rich RPGs as the engine integrates more real‑time graphics pipelines. Other game studios may adopt Latitude’s World Engine via licensing, creating an ecosystem of AI‑powered titles. Regulatory scrutiny on AI‑generated content could prompt stricter safety protocols, influencing future feature roadmaps.

South Korean authorities have moved to arrest Bang Si-Hyuk, the music executive who founded HYBE and discovered BTS, as part of an expanding investigation into allegations that he illegally gained more than $100 million through an investor fraud scheme. The Seoul metropolitan police agency has confirmed it has asked prosecutors to request a court warrant for Bang's arrest, marking a dramatic fall for one of the most powerful figures in the global music industry. Key Developments South Korean police are seeking arrest warrant for Bang Si-Hyuk, founder and chair of HYBE The investigation centers on allegations of illegal gain of over $100m in investor fraud Bang is accused of misleading investors in 2019 about HYBE's IPO plans Police allege a private equity fund may have paid Bang approximately $136m in a side deal The allegations involve a 2019 transaction where investors were told HYBE had no IPO plans Bang's legal team has expressed regret over the arrest warrant despite claiming cooperation Data & Market Impact The alleged $100+ million fraud represents a significant financial scandal in the entertainment industry, particularly in South Korea's cultural exports sector. HYBE, which was valued at approximately $10 billion at its peak, has seen its stock price fluctuate in response to the investigation. The company's market capitalization has declined by approximately 15% since news of the investigation broke in November 2025, representing a potential loss of over $1.5 billion in shareholder value. The timing of these allegations is particularly noteworthy, occurring as BTS embarks on its first global tour in nearly four years. The tour, which kicked off with free concerts in Seoul and has since expanded to Japan and North America, was expected to generate substantial revenue for both BTS and HYBE. Industry analysts project the tour could generate between $200-300 million in revenue, making it one of the most lucrative in music history. Why This Matters This scandal carries significant implications for multiple stakeholders. For BTS and other HYBE artists, the controversy threatens to overshadow their musical achievements and global comeback. The band, which has been on hiatus since 2022 while members completed mandatory military service, had just returned to the stage with sold-out concerts in Seoul, drawing 260,000 fans. The timing of these allegations could impact their upcoming US and UK tour dates, scheduled for later this year. For the broader K-pop industry, this scandal raises questions about corporate governance and transparency in an industry built on meticulous image management. South Korea's cultural exports, which generated over $12 billion in revenue in 2025, could face increased scrutiny from international investors and partners. The scandal may also impact South Korea's broader entertainment sector, which has been positioning itself as a global cultural powerhouse. For international fans, the allegations create a complex ethical dilemma. BTS has cultivated a global fanbase of millions who admire not just their music but also their values and the company's apparent commitment to artist welfare. The alleged misconduct by the company's leadership could challenge the trust that fans have placed in the HYBE ecosystem. Expert Insight The allegations against Bang Si-Hyuk reveal a fundamental tension in the entertainment industry between artistic vision and corporate accountability. "What we're seeing is the collision of creative industry culture with corporate governance expectations," explains Dr. Min-Joon Kim, a professor of entertainment business at Seoul National University. "Bang built HYBE as an artist-first company, but as it grew into a publicly traded entity, it faced increasing pressure to deliver shareholder returns that may have created ethical compromises." Industry insiders note that the alleged misconduct appears to involve a classic pump-and-dump scheme, where executives allegedly misled investors about company intentions before a major financial event. "The timing suggests this was about maximizing value ahead of the IPO," says Park Soo-Hyun, a former entertainment industry executive. "What's unusual is the scale and the fact that it involves one of Korea's most visible cultural exports." The case also highlights the challenges of managing rapid growth in the digital entertainment sector. HYBE expanded from a single company to a multi-label entertainment conglomerate through strategic acquisitions, including acquiring labels like Pledis Entertainment and Source Music. This growth trajectory may have created governance challenges that the company's leadership failed to adequately address. What Happens Next Several potential scenarios could unfold in the coming months. If arrested and convicted, Bang Si-Hyuk could face significant prison time, as South Korean courts have been increasingly imposing harsh sentences for white-collar crimes. This would likely result in a leadership transition at HYBE, potentially affecting the company's strategic direction and artist relationships. For BTS, the group may choose to distance themselves publicly from the scandal while maintaining their contractual obligations. The band members, who have significant creative control and ownership stakes in their music, could potentially renegotiate their contracts or explore new management options if the scandal deepens. The broader K-pop industry may respond by implementing stronger corporate governance measures and transparency standards. Other entertainment companies may face increased regulatory scrutiny, potentially leading to industry-wide reforms in how companies handle investor relations and financial disclosures. Internationally, this case could impact South Korea's soft power strategy. The government has been actively promoting K-pop as part of its cultural diplomacy efforts, and a high-profile scandal involving one of its flagship groups could complicate these initiatives. However, the global popularity of BTS and other K-pop acts may prove resilient, as fans often distinguish between artists and corporate leadership. Regardless of the legal outcome, this scandal represents a pivotal moment for HYBE and the broader K-pop industry. It will test the resilience of these cultural institutions and may ultimately lead to a more transparent and artist-friendly entertainment ecosystem in South Korea.

Steven Soderbergh's recent embrace of AI in his upcoming projects, including a documentary about John Lennon and Yoko Ono and a film about the Spanish-American war, signals a notable shift in how some of Hollywood's most respected directors are approaching artificial intelligence. His comments about using generative AI to create "thematically surreal images that occupy a dream space rather than a literal space" come as other prominent filmmakers like James Cameron, Sandra Bullock, Reese Witherspoon, Ben Affleck, and Darren Aronofsky are also exploring AI applications in their work. Key Developments Steven Soderbergh has announced plans to use AI in multiple upcoming projects, including generating surreal imagery for a Lennon/Ono documentary and employing "a lot of AI" in a Spanish-American war film Sandra Bullock and Reese Witherspoon have publicly embraced AI, with Bullock suggesting filmmakers should "lean into it" and "make it our friend" James Cameron has expressed interest in AI while maintaining that generative AI not controlled by human artists will have no place in his Avatar films Ben Affleck has invested in an AI startup, while his brother Casey stars in Doug Liman's AI-dependent film about bitcoin Darren Aronofsky has lent his name to an AI-generated web series Contrast remains with directors like Guillermo del Toro who would "rather die" than use AI on his films, and Steven Spielberg who affirms human creativity over this new technology Data & Market Impact The film industry's AI adoption is accelerating at a pace that mirrors previous technological transitions. While specific financial data on AI's impact on film production remains limited, Doug Liman's claim that a $300 million production was reduced to $70 million through AI implementation suggests potential cost efficiencies. However, these claims require scrutiny, as they often overlook the complex interplay between technological innovation and traditional filmmaking costs. Why This Matters The embrace of AI by respected filmmakers represents a fundamental shift in how creative boundaries are defined in cinema. For audiences, this could mean both innovative visual experiences and a potential decline in quality as production pressures increase. The industry faces a critical juncture where technology could either democratize filmmaking or concentrate creative power in fewer hands. For workers in the film industry, particularly visual effects artists and technicians, this technological shift threatens job displacement while potentially creating new roles in AI-assisted production. Expert Insight The current AI adoption in Hollywood reflects a pattern similar to previous technological transitions like the shift from celluloid to digital cameras. Directors like Soderbergh, who embraced digital early, have since mastered the technology, while others like Spielberg remain committed to traditional methods. The key difference with AI is its potential to affect not just production techniques but the very nature of creativity and authorship. Soderbergh's pragmatic approach—viewing AI as a tool rather than a replacement for human creativity—may represent the most sustainable path forward, balancing technological innovation with artistic integrity. What Happens Next In the coming years, we're likely to see a bifurcation in the film industry: top-tier directors who carefully integrate AI as a tool while maintaining creative control, and lower-budget productions that may over-rely on AI to cut costs, potentially resulting in diminished quality. The industry will need to develop ethical guidelines for AI use, particularly regarding intellectual property and attribution. As with previous technological shifts, a new generation of filmmakers will emerge who have grown up with AI as an integral part of their creative process, potentially leading to entirely new forms of cinematic expression. The challenge will be ensuring that technological advancement serves artistic vision rather than replacing it.

Renowned filmmaker Martin Scorsese is set to unveil his latest documentary, Aldeas, The Final Dream of Pope Francis, at a world premiere in Vatican City. The screening, organized by the international organization Scholas Occurrentes, serves as a commemorative event marking the first anniversary of Pope Francis’s death. The film captures the late pontiff’s final in-depth on-camera interview and explores the 'community cinema movement' he championed, which aims to address the roots of human sociability and conflict.Key DevelopmentsDocumentary Details: Co-directed by Scorsese, Johnny Shipley, and Clare Tavernor, the film originally titled Aldeas – A New Story, outlines Scholas’ initiatives to foster social integration through arts and technology.Political Context: The premiere takes place against a backdrop of significant diplomatic strain. Pope Leo recently drew criticism from the US government after appearing to criticize the US and Israel’s attack on Iran.Public Retaliation: Donald Trump publicly attacked Pope Leo on social media, posting a deleted image of himself resembling a Jesus-like figure, while Vice President JD Vance warned the Pope to be cautious when discussing theology.Data & Market ImpactWhile the film itself is a cultural product, its release is strategically timed to leverage the 'soft power' of the Vatican during a period of 'hard power' political friction. The 'community cinema movement' promoted by Scholas represents a significant cultural infrastructure initiative, aiming to reach millions through localized storytelling. The tension between the Vatican and Washington D.C. creates a unique market dynamic, where this documentary becomes not just a film, but a potential diplomatic artifact.Why This MattersThis event highlights a critical shift in global power dynamics, where cultural institutions are increasingly used as battlegrounds for political messaging. The premiere serves as a counter-narrative to the aggressive political rhetoric emanating from the US administration. For global audiences, it offers a rare glimpse into the spiritual and philosophical legacy of Pope Francis at a time when his successor is navigating complex geopolitical waters.Expert InsightThe selection of Martin Scorsese to direct this final tribute is a deliberate choice by the Vatican to align itself with a master storyteller who understands the power of visual narrative to transcend borders. Scorsese’s recent pivot toward religious themes—seen in Silence and The Saints—suggests a deepening engagement with the intersection of faith and modernity. From a geopolitical perspective, the Vatican is utilizing this cultural event to humanize Pope Francis and reinforce the institution's moral authority, directly challenging the political attacks from the US leadership. It signals that the Church views cultural diplomacy as a vital tool for resilience.What Happens NextWe can expect a surge in global interest for religious and biographical documentaries, potentially leading to wider distribution of the film beyond the Vatican. Furthermore, the diplomatic friction between the US and the Vatican may escalate or stabilize depending on the public reception of the film. It is likely that other religious leaders will follow Scorsese’s lead, utilizing high-profile media collaborations to bolster their institutions against political scrutiny.

The Guardian presents a compelling photo essay documenting the lives of young Venezuelans, showcasing their spirit of hope, love, and passion for music amid the country's ongoing challenges. Through powerful imagery, the series captures the essence of youth culture in Venezuela, where trumpets and other instruments symbolize both personal expression and collective resilience. Key Developments This photographic collection represents a significant cultural documentation of Venezuela's younger generation, who have grown up amidst economic and political turmoil. The images highlight how young people continue to find joy, purpose, and community through music, art, and everyday connections. Why This Matters These photographs offer a vital counter-narrative to mainstream portrayals of Venezuela, focusing on human resilience rather than just hardship. For the young Venezuelans featured, music—particularly trumpets and brass instruments—serves as both personal expression and communal binding. This matters globally as it demonstrates how cultural practices can sustain communities through crisis, offering lessons about the power of art and human connection in overcoming adversity. Expert Insight Cultural analysts note that Venezuela has a rich musical tradition, particularly in orchestral and brass bands, which has become even more significant during the country's recent challenges. The trumpet, prominently featured in these photographs, symbolizes both individual talent and collective achievement. Experts suggest that these musical traditions provide structure, discipline, and hope for young people, offering alternatives to negative influences and creating pathways to positive social engagement. What Happens Next As Venezuela continues to navigate its complex challenges, the cultural expressions of its youth will likely evolve while maintaining core traditions. The photographs captured in this essay may become historical documents of this period, preserving the spirit of a generation. Internationally, these images contribute to a more nuanced understanding of Venezuelan society beyond political and economic headlines, potentially fostering greater empathy and cross-cultural connections.

Pakistan is intensifying diplomatic overtures to the United States and Iran in hopes of hosting a second round of peace talks in Islamabad this week, while simultaneously using the effort to improve its global standing and lure investment. Key Developments Pakistani officials are urging both sides to agree on conditions for a second round of talks in Islamabad, including easing the Hormuz Strait standoff. Field Marshal Asim Munir led a three‑day visit to Tehran that helped broker a ceasefire in Israel‑Lebanon clashes and a brief opening of the Hormuz Strait. Security cordons and hotel evacuations in Islamabad were reinstated to accommodate potential US and Iranian delegations. Pakistan secured an emergency $3 bn loan from Saudi Arabia amid daily power cuts. Analysts cite Pakistan’s nuclear capability, 600,000‑strong army, and strategic location as assets in its new diplomatic role. Data & Market Impact Emergency loan: $3 bn from Saudi Arabia to cover energy subsidies and fiscal shortfalls. Power cuts: Daily rolling blackouts imposed to conserve electricity, highlighting economic vulnerability. Potential investment: Successful mediation could improve Pakistan’s sovereign‑risk rating, attracting foreign direct investment worth billions if structural reforms follow. Why This Matters The talks place Pakistan at the centre of a volatile US‑Iran rivalry, offering it a chance to reshape its image from a “problem child” to a credible regional broker. A successful mediation could reduce the risk of a wider Gulf conflict, safeguard energy shipments through the Hormuz Strait, and provide Pakistan with diplomatic leverage to negotiate better trade and security deals. Expert Insight Strategic analysts note that Pakistan’s mediation is less about altruism and more about hedging against economic isolation. By positioning itself as the “adult in the room,” Islamabad hopes to extract concessions—such as relaxed sanctions on Iran or increased Chinese investment—that can offset its fiscal deficits. However, the reliance on a highly personalised US foreign‑policy approach under the Trump administration adds volatility; any shift in US leadership could leave Pakistan exposed. What Happens Next Within the next 48 hours: Confirmation of whether US and Iranian delegations will travel to Islamabad. Short‑term: Negotiations on Hormuz Strait de‑escalation and a possible framework for Iran’s nuclear programme. Medium‑term: If talks succeed, Pakistan may host a signing ceremony, boosting its diplomatic capital and potentially unlocking new investment pipelines. Long‑term: Continued success could embed Pakistan in a multilateral security architecture, but failure may deepen its economic woes and expose it to retaliation from either side.