Breaking AI & Tech News Analyzed

The Lead: Ending the 22-Year DroughtArsenal have ended a 22-year wait to be crowned Premier League champions after Manchester City were held 1-1 by Bournemouth. Mikel Arteta's men held off the challenge of Pep Guardiola's second-place City to seal a long-awaited triumph with one game to spare.Tactical Innovation: The Set Piece RevolutionArsenal's title-winning campaign has been built on a back-to-basics approach that has revolutionized their set-piece strategy. For a couple of seasons, Arteta's Arsenal have been the emblem of a more pragmatic approach in English football, moving away from the era of pretty passing under Guardiola and heavy-metal football under Jurgen Klopp.The Gunners have mastered set pieces with Gabriel Magalhaes a menace at corners, Declan Rice key with his pinpoint throws and dead-ball deliveries, and Victor Gyokeres providing a robust striking option. More than 40 percent of Arsenal's Premier League goals this season have come from dead ball situations, with 18 of their 28 set-piece goals coming from corners – a new single-season Premier League record.Key Performances: Leadership Between the Posts and in MidfieldDeclan Rice and goalkeeper David Raya have stood out for Arsenal this season, putting them among the favorites for English football's Player of the Year award. Rice's leadership, energy in midfield, and set-piece delivery have made him an integral member of the team and one of England's key players heading into the World Cup.Raya has helped Arsenal keep 19 clean sheets, earning him the Golden Glove award for the third straight year. "David Raya, for me, has to be the player of the season," former Arsenal captain Patrick Vieira told Sky Sports. "I think he was outstanding from the first game until the end of the season. I think he was really impressive."Throw in Gyokeres scoring 21 goals in all competitions in his first season at the club, and it is clear that Arteta has built the most well-rounded team of his tenure.Squad Depth: Overcoming the Injury CrisisInjuries played a ruinous role in Arsenal's failed pursuit of Liverpool last season. However, the decision to invest heavily in bulking out Arteta's squad paid off this season despite injuries to key players like Saka, Magalhaes, Martin Odegaard, Kai Havertz, and Jurrien Timber.New signings Gyokeres, Eberechi Eze, Martin Zubimendi, Noni Madueke, Piero Hincapie, and Cristhian Mosquera have all made significant contributions to get Arsenal over the line in the Premier League and within one game of winning the Champions League for the first time.Mental Fortitude: Building Resilience Through AdversityFinishing as runners-up in the Premier League for the past three years saw Arsenal's players and Arteta derided as "nearly men", even chokers, by many football pundits. However, this period built up the prerequisite experience and resolve to finally launch a successful tilt at the title.Arteta kept believing in his squad and came up with unorthodox methods to inspire his players. A professional pickpocket was reportedly hired for a preseason dinner to highlight the need for alertness, while a lightbulb was brought into the locker room before one game to demand that the team "shine" at Emirates Stadium. Recently, TikTok videos featuring fan chants were played on big screens during practice sessions.Arsenal have been mentally tougher this season, holding on after yet another strong start and seeing it through to the end despite City's trademark late-season rally.The Competitive Landscape: When 82 Points Was EnoughArsenal accumulated more points two years ago when they were pipped to the title by City despite winning 16 of their final 18 games. Over the past decade, City and Liverpool have often set the bar high, winning the league with more than 90 points.This time, 82 was enough to see Arsenal over the line. Despite taking the title race into the final week of the campaign, City lacked the same consistency and relentlessness of Guardiola's best sides while Liverpool's title defense imploded.

The Great Greenwashing: When Sustainability Meets Fast Fashion It was always about the money, wasn't it? For a while there, it seemed like the execs opining "sustainability is not a trend, it's the future" actually meant it. But when yet another global brand drops its net zero goals or stops talking about DEI, you do wonder. Recent headlines include Stella McCartney adulterating her eco gloss with a sustainable capsule collection for H&M; – don't worry, she's just "infiltrating from within" – and Lululemon being investigated for PFAS. The letdowns keep coming. The Everlane-Shein Merger: A Collision of Ideals Now the internet is reeling from a report that Shein plans to acquire Everlane, the San Francisco-based sustainable basics brand built on "radical transparency". Shein is the Chinese ultra-fast fashion giant epitomising murky supply chains and crazy-cheap landfill fashion. They release up to 10,000 styles a day, and have been making headlines of their own over secrecy and alleged links to forced Uyghur labor. Fashion reporter Lauren Sherman reported the acquisition plans this week, though neither Shein nor Everlane have confirmed. Everlane appears to be losing money fast. After layoffs in 2020 and 2023, the brand confirmed in April it was closing its San Francisco office. The Financial Calculus Behind Sustainable Fashion's Fall According to Sherman, Shein sees value in the brand's supply chain and was the only one willing to stump up the US $100m asked by Everlane's majority owner, private equity giant L Catterton (which is backed by LVMH, and owned RM Williams before Australian billionaire Andrew Forrest bought it in 2020). Shein can afford it – last year, their sales topped £2bn in the UK and $1.5bn in Australia. For my money, I bet it's not just the practical capabilities of the supply chain that interests Shein, it's the story. They could use a green glow-up. The Shifting Landscape of Ethical Fashion The Everlane tragedy follows last month's Allbirds comedy. Another publicly listed sustainable fashion company driven by Silicon Valley hype, Allbirds has given up making sneakers out of carbon neutral materials in order to flog AI. The surprise pivot came with a name change – NewBird – and a cynical cash grab. The old bird had been leaking money; the new one sent stock surging 600%. I visited Allbirds HQ the same year I interviewed Preysman. We discussed their B Corp journey, material innovation and how co-founder Joey Zwillinger reckoned "at the end of the day, people don't buy sustainable products, they buy great product experiences". I titled the podcast episode 'The Eco-Awesomeness of Allbirds – Sustainable Shoes for Changemakers'. The Future of Sustainability: Beyond Greenwashing So how do we navigate this moment? Accept it: sustainability is not hot right now. OK! This was never meant to be a popularity contest. The movement needs to get back to basics. Circularity won't save us – we must focus on workers' rights and the just transition. Have hard conversations about overproduction. Dismantle consumerism as the dominant narrative and define a properly radical approach to system change. You can't take the politics out of this, but why would you want to? As the last few months have shown us, when sustainability becomes purely about the business case, it stops meaning anything at all.

The Lead: Arsenal's Long-Awaited Triumph After an incredible 984 days at the top of the table without being champions, Arsenal Football Club has finally ended their 19-year Premier League drought. The club's faithful supporters, who have waited since the unforgettable 2003-04 season when Arsène Wenger's Invincibles went the top-flight campaign unbeaten, can now celebrate as Mikel Arteta's side has proven they are capable of holding their nerve when it matters most. The Event Details: Arteta's Transformation Journey The ever-meticulous Arteta arrived at the club a week before Christmas in 2019 on a mission to restore them to former glories. After spending his first three months talking to "everybody at the club with a lot of different roles," he introduced the olive tree dating back to 1886 when Arsenal was founded, symbolizing the roots of the club and the culture he was attempting to foster. After laying down a marker in December 2021 when the former captain Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang was jettisoned after one indiscretion too many, the manager has been allowed to build a squad in his image by American owners happy to trust in his expertise. The Data Analysis: Building a Championship Squad Arsenal's executives remained quietly convinced this would be their year after an outlay of £250m on eight arrivals, including Eberechi Eze from Crystal Palace for £67.5m and Viktor Gyökeres for £64m. All but Christian Nørgaard have made an impact, although a defence that has largely been together for the past three seasons has formed the bedrock of Arsenal's title. Set pieces have played a massive role in their success, breaking the Premier League record for goals scored from corners against Chelsea on 1 March and extending it to 19 against Burnley. More than a third of their 69 goals – the fifth-lowest by the champions in Premier League history – came from set pieces. The Impact Analysis: Changing the Football Landscape Arsenal's triumph represents a significant shift in the balance of power in English football. After years of Manchester City and Liverpool dominance, Arteta's side has proven that financial resources alone don't guarantee success. The club's ability to respond to setbacks – particularly after their disastrous April when they lost twice to Manchester City in a run of four consecutive domestic defeats – demonstrates a newfound resilience. The appointment of Andrea Berta as the new sporting director last March proved a pivotal moment in the club's evolution, with considerable input from Arteta helping to assemble a squad capable of withstanding almost any injury crisis. The Prediction: The Future of Arsenal Football Club With Arsenal set to appear in their second Champions League final, the future looks exceptionally bright for the North London club. The Kroenkes, whose sports empire is estimated to be worth about $23bn (£17bn), have promised in their joint programme notes that "there will be no standing still when the season ends. We are always forward in our approach and relentless in the pursuit of progress." Arteta is poised to sign a lucrative contract extension that will reward his success, and the club's academy products like Bukayo Saka suggest sustainable success is on the horizon. Even if they can't join the elite group of clubs to have achieved the double by beating Paris Saint-Germain in Budapest, Arsenal has firmly reestablished themselves as a force to be reckoned with in both English and European football.

The End of an Era: Google's AI-Powered Search RevolutionGoogle has officially announced the most significant transformation of Search in its 25+ year history, replacing the traditional "ten blue links" model with AI-powered interactive experiences and information agents that will perform searches on behalf of users. This fundamental shift will change how people access information online, moving from a simple list of links to dynamic, personalized experiences.The Intelligent Search Box: A New Beginning for Web DiscoveryGoogle unveiled on Tuesday an AI-powered overhaul of Search centered around a reimagined "intelligent search box" that expands to accommodate longer, more conversational queries. Instead of requiring users to select specific search modes, the new system uses AI to understand context and provide more nuanced results. The search experience will now include AI-powered query suggestions that go beyond traditional autocomplete, helping users craft more complex questions.AI Overviews and Interactive ExperiencesThe revamped Search experience introduces several key features that mark a departure from Google's traditional approach. AI Overviews, already used by more than 2.5 billion monthly users, will now allow follow-up questions in AI Mode. Additionally, Google is introducing "generative UI" capabilities that build custom widgets and visualizations on the fly in response to search queries. For example, a question about black holes could lead to an interactive visual that brings the concept to life, with users able to ask follow-up questions and receive new visuals in real-time.The Rise of Information Agents: Beyond Google AlertsStarting this summer, users will be able to create, customize, and manage multiple "information agents" within Google Search. These agents represent an evolution of Google's 2003 Google Alerts service, but with significantly enhanced capabilities. Unlike the original alerts that simply notified users of new web results, these AI-powered agents can work 24/7 in the background to track changes on the web, make sense of them, and alert users when specific conditions are met. For instance, users could create an agent to track market movements with very specific parameters, which would then provide synthesized updates with relevant links and information.Building the Future: Custom Mini Apps in SearchGoogle is also introducing tools that allow users to build personalized mini apps directly within Search using natural-language commands. Powered by Google's Antigravity platform, these stateful experiences can be tailored to individual needs. Examples include a meal-planning app that integrates with a user's calendar or a fitness app created for specific goals. This shift represents a move from information retrieval to action, with Google providing the tools for users to create experiences rather than just find information.The Numbers Behind the TransformationGoogle's AI-powered search features are already seeing massive adoption. AI Overviews are used by more than 2.5 billion monthly users, while the conversational search mode, AI Mode, launched last year, now tops 1 billion monthly users. For comparison, ChatGPT has 900 million weekly active users as of earlier this year. This suggests that while ChatGPT sees more frequent engagement, Google has more total unique users accessing its AI features monthly. The new system was built in partnership with Google DeepMind and uses Gemini Flash 3.5.Industry Disruption: The Impact on Publishers and Content CreatorsThese changes are likely to further decimate Google referrals to publishers, which have already been suffering from declining referrals due to AI Overviews. Some ad-dependent media operations have already been forced out of business, and the new search experience may accelerate this trend. With users spending less time clicking traditional blue links and more time interacting with AI-generated content and agents, publishers will face significant challenges in maintaining traffic and revenue. The timeline for this transformation is aggressive, with the new search box arriving immediately and generative UI coming this summer, both free of charge.The Road Ahead: Google's Vision for AI-Powered SearchGoogle's long-term plan is to make its AI technology more broadly accessible, including its personal AI agent Spark, which will eventually be free. The company is focusing on delivering "frontier models" that are highly capable yet efficient and cost-effective to ensure widespread adoption. While information agents and mini-app building features will roll out first to Google AI Pro and Ultra subscribers this summer, the company's ultimate goal is to democratize access to these advanced AI capabilities. This transformation represents not just a change in how search works, but a fundamental shift in how humans interact with information on the web.

The Race for Bowen IntensifiesChelsea, Liverpool, and Manchester United are all interested in Jarrod Bowen as rival clubs prepare to capitalize on West Ham's financial problems by targeting their best players. The England winger has become the subject of intense transfer speculation as West Ham faces the very real threat of relegation from the Premier League.Bowen's West Ham Legacy and Current FormThe 29-year-old has been outstanding for West Ham since joining from Hull in January 2020 and his status as one of the most loved players in the club's history is not in doubt. This season, he has registered a combined 21 goals and assists, demonstrating his consistent attacking prowess. Bowen scored the winning goal when West Ham beat Fiorentina in the Conference League final in 2020, cementing his place in the club's recent history.Financial Pressure at West HamWest Ham will need to raise more than £100m if relegated from the Premier League, creating significant financial pressure. The club made a £104.2m loss in the last financial year and will need to make sales even if they avoid relegation. With Tottenham potentially taking a point from either of their final two games, West Ham's fate could be sealed this week, forcing them into a position where they must consider selling their most valuable assets.Clubs' Strategic Interest in BowenEach of the interested clubs views Bowen differently based on their current squad needs:Liverpool have long been admirers of Bowen and could target him as they look to boost their forward options.Manchester United are keen to add more depth in attack after qualifying for the Champions League and regard Bowen's versatility as a big plus. He predominantly plays on the right but can operate as a central striker and United are considering him as an option on the left wing.Chelsea are another intriguing option. They have focused on signing young players but are keen to add more experience. Their interest in Bowen is not at an advanced stage but they believe he could offer competition on the right and potentially provide cover for their strikers.Bowen's Future and West Ham's DilemmaBowen has stayed loyal to West Ham and is thought to be happy in London, but relegation could force him to reassess his priorities. With his contract not expiring until 2030, West Ham would likely command a substantial fee for their star winger. The club faces the difficult decision of potentially losing one of their most popular players while needing to raise significant funds, with other targets including Mateus Fernandes (with interest from Arsenal, United and Paris Saint-Germain) and Dutch winger Crysencio Summerville also up for sale.

The Return of Brazil's Star PlayerWhen coach Carlo Ancelotti read aloud the list of players who made the cut to Brazil's World Cup squad, one name earned the loudest cheers: Neymar Jr. After months of sweating over his fitness, the 34-year-old forward breathed a sigh of relief as he earned a place in Brazil's 26-man squad for the tournament in North America, which begins on June 11.His return to the national team, following a two-and-a-half-year hiatus, has come with its own share of drama and doubts. Brazil coach Ancelotti said he chose Neymar among the nine attackers after seeing an improvement in his fitness levels.The Fitness ControversyNeymar da Silva Santos Jr is Brazil's all-time leading scorer. But his selection to the squad was considered doubtful after a series of injuries kept him out for much of the Selecao's qualifying campaign for the 2026 tournament, where they are aiming for a record-extending sixth title."We evaluated Neymar throughout the year and noticed that recently he has been playing consistently and has improved his physical condition," Ancelotti told reporters during Monday's squad announcement in Rio de Janeiro. "He has the same role and responsibilities as everyone else, but he is an experienced player. It's true that in some positions we prioritised experience."The simple answer to the controversy is injuries. Neymar struggled to return to top fitness and had not been part of the national team since suffering a serious knee injury – an anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) tear – in October 2023. An injury-marred spell at Saudi club Al Hilal and an underwhelming return to his boyhood club Santos last year further cast doubts over the veteran's inclusion.World Cup Records and StatisticsThe 2026 tournament will be Neymar's fourth World Cup. He played at the 2014 edition on home soil, followed by Russia 2018 and then the last World Cup in Qatar four years ago. In 13 games across three World Cups, Neymar has scored eight times and registered four assists.He also boasts the impressive record of being Brazil's highest scorer with 79 goals, a feat he achieved by surpassing Brazilian great Pele, who was their outright leading marksman for 60 years. His four goals and two assists in the Brazilian Serie A 2026 – following his return from surgery in February – are a far cry from his usual top form, one that once saw him win two La Liga titles and a Champions League trophy with Barcelona, and five Ligue 1 crowns with Paris Saint-German (PSG).National Celebration and SupportDespite being away from the national team since late 2023, Neymar still holds a special place in the hearts of Brazil fans and players alike. As World Cup selections were revealed, hundreds of fans gathered outside Rio de Janeiro's Museum of Tomorrow, holding up their phones, frantically waiting for Ancelotti to announce the name of their beloved superstar.And when Neymar's inclusion was finally confirmed inside the venue, a party-like atmosphere swept across parts of the football-crazy South American nation. Players, too, have been vocal about their support for Neymar. Marcelo, the former Brazil defender, celebrated Neymar's inclusion with a post on Instagram, punching his fist in the air after seeing the announcement on a TV screen, while Barcelona star Raphinha, who was also called up, told TV Globo earlier this month that Neymar is "the guy to take us to our sixth World Cup title".Captain Marquinhos was at the forefront of the players' public lobbying for Neymar's inclusion, saying to Brazilian website UOL in March: "As teammates, as Brazilians and as fans, we want him at the World Cup".A Final World Cup Appearance?With his history of injuries and fitness issues, a declining skill set, as well as his mounting age (he would be 38 by the 2030 tournament), it's highly unlikely that Neymar will feature at another World Cup. Whether Ancelotti's decision to include him for the 2026 tournament will backfire or prove to be another coaching masterstroke by the Italian manager remains to be seen.

Neymar's Return to Brazil: Redemption and National HopeNeymar is Brazil's record goalscorer but hasn't played for the national team for three years. He was part of the greatest attack of all time – MSN – but never won a Ballon d'Or. A generational talent who arguably butchered his career with money-fuelled moves to PSG and Saudi Arabia. After too many off-pitch controversies to count – only this month, he slapped a Santos teammate, Robinho Jr, in training – Neymar will be remembered as much for knack (including the injury that kept him out of that 7-1 defeat by Germany – as he will for the nutmegs, the rainbow flicks, the Remontada heroics, his Pausa, Bigger Cup triumphs, and Puskas Award goal. The overarching feeling for many is "yes, what a player", but also, "what a waste".That is, at least, the view from Europe, and when it comes to the Geopolitics World Cup that view matters not one jot. Simply put, the European mind (save for Carlo Ancelotti, of course) cannot comprehend how different the standpoint is in Brazil, where Neymar remains a sort of demi-deity – seemingly the last bastion of jogo bonito and the essence of the Selecao; both a symbol of its glorious past and its recent struggle. No Brazil team has ever gone longer than the current 24-year World Cup drought. After decades of collective suffering – Neymar and Brazil are in desperate need of redemption and glory. In a deeply Catholic country, those themes are overwhelmingly seductive.The Controversial Journey of Brazil's Record GoalscorerOne only needs to watch the videos of people reacting to Neymar's inclusion in Ancelotti's Brazil squad to get a sense of it. Grown men were reduced to hot salty tears of joy (and fits of destruction), there were parties in the streets and schoolchildren – so young that they were not even born when Neymar was in his Barcelona pomp – chanted wildly in celebration, apparently hard-wired in their devotion. "Neymar will be an important player for us at the World Cup," soothed Ancelotti. "We realised that in this last period he had continuity and was in good physical condition." Not to mention 11 goals and four assists in his last 18 matches for a relegation-threatened Santos.Neymar's domestic form and a complete lack of it for João Pedro in a Brazil shirt – no goals or assists in eight appearances to date – is probably lost on many commentators and Social Media Disgrace influencers complaining on Tuesday at Ancelotti's omission of the Chelsea forward. And while that was a surprise, it's probably best not to question Ancelotti, one of the greatest managers of all time with five Bigger Cups to his name. You're better off with Ancelotti than without him and if you don't believe that, just have a look at how Real Madrid are doing at the moment.Brazil's 24-Year World Cup Drought and the Weight of ExpectationIn a deeply Catholic country, themes of redemption and glory are overwhelmingly seductive. Neymar represents more than just football talent to Brazilians – he embodies their hopes for ending the longest World Cup drought in the nation's history. The emotional reaction to his selection speaks volumes about the pressure and expectation placed on both the player and the team. While European critics focus on his controversial career moves and off-field incidents, Brazilians see in Neymar the potential to restore national pride and deliver the glory they've been waiting for a generation.The contrast between European perception and Brazilian adoration couldn't be starker. While many in Europe view Neymar's career as a waste of potential, in Brazil he remains a demi-deity – the last bastion of jogo bonito and the essence of the Selecao. This cultural divide highlights how differently football is viewed across continents, with Brazil's collective suffering making their need for redemption all the more acute.Can Neymar Deliver Brazil's World Cup Dream?The question now is whether Neymar can deliver on the immense weight of expectation. At 34 years old, he may be in the twilight of his international career, but his recent form suggests he still possesses the quality to make a difference. With 11 goals and four assists in his last 18 matches for Santos, despite playing for a relegation-threatened team, he has proven he can still deliver at the highest level.Carlo Ancelotti's decision to include Neymar, despite the controversy, signals a belief that the veteran star can still be an important player for Brazil. The Italian manager, one of the greatest in the game with five European Cups to his name, clearly sees value in Neymar's experience and quality. Whether this gamble pays off remains to be seen, but for a nation starved of success, Neymar represents their best hope of ending their World Cup drought and bringing glory back to Brazil.

The Recall of Ross Stewart Scotland's manager Steve Clarke has included striker Ross Stewart in the 26-man squad for the upcoming World Cup, marking his return to international football after a four-year absence. Stewart's recent form for Southampton, scoring five goals in 10 games, prompted his recall. Scotland's World Cup Squad The squad features a mix of experienced players and young talents. Goalkeepers include Craig Gordon, Angus Gunn, and Liam Kelly. Defenders are Grant Hanley, Jack Hendry, Aaron Hickey, Dom Hyam, Scott McKenna, Nathan Patterson, Anthony Ralston, Andy Robertson, John Souttar, and Kieran Tierney. Goalkeepers: Craig Gordon, Angus Gunn, Liam Kelly Defenders: Grant Hanley, Jack Hendry, Aaron Hickey, Dom Hyam, Scott McKenna, Nathan Patterson, Anthony Ralston, Andy Robertson, John Souttar, Kieran Tierney Midfielders: Ryan Christie, Findlay Curtis, Lewis Ferguson, Ben Gannon-Doak, Billy Gilmour, John McGinn, Kenny McLean, Scott McTominay Forwards: Ché Adams, Lyndon Dykes, George Hirst, Lawrence Shankland, Ross Stewart The Impact of Stewart's Recall Stewart's inclusion is a significant boost to Scotland's attacking options. His recent form for Southampton has been impressive, and Clarke believes he can make an impact in the World Cup. The World Cup Campaign Scotland's World Cup campaign kicks off against Haiti in Boston on 13 June, followed by matches against Morocco and Brazil. The team will also play pre-tournament friendlies against Curaçao and Bolivia.

The Lead A US jury has handed a resounding victory to Sam Altman and OpenAI in their long, bitter courtroom battle with Elon Musk, finding Altman, OpenAI, and its president, Greg Brockman, not liable for Musk's claims that they unjustly enriched themselves and broke a founding contract. The Court Ruling and Its Implications The unanimous verdict, delivered after less than two hours of deliberation, is a stark rebuke of Musk and his lawyer's claims that Altman 'stole a charity' through his leadership of OpenAI. The jury's decision, affirmed immediately by the judge's dismissal of all charges, provides OpenAI with a stamp of approval for its for-profit plans, already in motion, and a clear path ahead to go public later this year at around a $1tn valuation. The Financial Impact Musk's demands that Altman be removed as CEO and that the for-profit arm of the company transfer some $150bn to the non-profit arm would have jeopardized the blockbuster initial public offering. A delay to OpenAI's financial bonanza may have been one of Musk's goals, as his own company, SpaceX, is reportedly planning to go public in June. The Industry Impact OpenAI's plans now seem all but guaranteed, given that the world's richest man couldn't put a stop to them. Wall Street, ever wary of upheaval and uncertainty, is likely breathing a sigh of relief, said professor Sarah Kreps, director of the Tech Policy Institute at Cornell University. She called the ruling a reflection of the tough reality that developing frontier AI is expensive and that maintaining non-profit status is not viable in the face of fierce, capital-intensive competition. The Future Outlook The trial did not deliver answers to major questions of the AI boom about safety, governance, and labor. While the jury's verdict was a 'technical' one, Musk's lawyers said he would appeal the case. The trial demonstrated that a small cabal, mostly men, rules the AI industry, and its central element was not a fight over AI's benefit to humanity but a hateful vendetta that Musk brought against Altman.