Breaking AI & Tech News Analyzed

The outbreak of armed conflict across the Gulf has sent shockwaves through the world of sport, where billions of dollars in sponsorships and broadcasting rights are traditionally tied to state‑linked conglomerates. As the war drags on, clubs, leagues and governing bodies are forced to rethink their financial playbooks. How the Gulf Conflict Is Undermining Traditional Sports Sponsorships Historically, the Gulf’s sovereign wealth funds and oil‑rich corporations have been the backbone of sponsorship deals for football clubs, tennis tournaments, and motorsport events. The current hostilities have triggered: Immediate suspension of 12 major sponsorship contracts worth an estimated $1.2 billion across Europe and Asia. Travel bans affecting athletes and staff from the region, leading to logistical challenges for international competitions. Currency volatility that makes long‑term payment commitments risky for both sponsors and clubs. Financial Fallout: Numbers Behind the Sponsorship Pullback Early data from the European Sports Finance Association (ESFA) shows a sharp dip in Gulf‑linked revenue streams: Football clubs reported a 15 % decline in total sponsorship income for Q1 2026 compared with Q1 2025. Formula 1 lost $250 million in Gulf‑based advertising after the Abu Dhabi Grand Prix was postponed. Tennis tournaments in the Middle East faced a 30 % reduction in prize‑money pools due to sponsor withdrawals. Broader Implications for Global Sports Leagues The ripple effect extends beyond the immediate loss of cash: Leagues are renegotiating broadcast rights to include clauses that protect against geopolitical disruptions. Clubs are accelerating the development of digital fan‑engagement platforms to generate direct revenue from merchandise and subscription services. Investor confidence in sports‑related assets is being recalibrated, with a noticeable shift toward ESG‑aligned funds that avoid conflict‑prone regions. What the Next Five Years May Hold for Sports Financing Analysts forecast a multi‑phase evolution: Short term (1‑2 years): Clubs will seek emergency financing from private equity and sovereign funds outside the conflict zone. Medium term (3‑5 years): A rise in multinational consortium sponsorships that diversify risk across regions. Long term: Integration of blockchain‑based tokenized ownership models, allowing fans to invest directly in clubs, reducing reliance on traditional corporate sponsors. In sum, the Gulf war is reshaping the financial architecture of sport, pushing stakeholders toward more resilient, diversified, and technology‑driven revenue models.

The Executive SummaryEmployers are increasingly skeptical of the four‑day workweek label, seeing it as a threat to profitability despite growing legislative support and AI‑driven productivity promises.Employer Backlash Over the Four‑Day Workweek LabelWhen you mention “four‑day workweek” to a typical manager, the reaction is often an eye roll. Executives argue that paying five days’ wages for four days of work feels unfair, especially when they are already juggling countless deals.Legislative pilots in Europe—Belgium, Iceland and Lithuania—have mandated shorter weeks, and hundreds of UK firms have signed up for trials, yet many businesses remain hesitant.Adoption Figures and Labor Market PressuresBelgium, Iceland, Lithuania: national legislation requiring a four‑day week.UK: hundreds of companies have signed up for permanent trials.US tech leaders (Jamie Dimon, Elon Musk, Sam Altman) predict AI will eventually shrink the workweek.UK labour market: millions of job openings remain unfilled, driving employers to seek more hours, not fewer.Why the Stigma Undermines Flexible Work ArrangementsThe phrase “four‑day workweek” has become shorthand for laziness in the eyes of many senior leaders. This perception pushes companies to offer flexibility through remote work, compressed schedules, or generous paid‑time‑off instead of openly adopting the shorter week.Examples from the field show the concept already exists under different names: three 12‑hour shifts for full pay in veterinary practice, 10‑hour shifts with extra days off in manufacturing, and extensive PTO packages that effectively create a four‑day rhythm.Rebranding the Shorter Week for an AI‑Enhanced FutureIf AI delivers the promised productivity gains, the workweek may indeed shrink, but executives are likely to avoid the “four‑day” tag. New terminology such as “performance‑pay model,” “smart‑hours,” or “results‑based scheduling” could make the idea more palatable.By decoupling the benefits from the stigmatized label, businesses can retain talent, reduce turnover, and still reap the efficiency gains that AI offers.

Executive Summary: Ryanair Pulls Out of Berlin Amid Tax and Fuel PressuresRyanair will close its Berlin operating base, halving its winter schedule and moving seven aircraft to other hubs. The airline blames the decision on Germany’s rising aviation taxes and a doubling of jet‑fuel prices since the Gulf conflict began.Ryanair Announces Closure of Berlin Base Over Soaring Aviation TaxesCEO Eddie Wilson confirmed that passenger traffic will fall from 4.5 million to 2.2 million annually, with flights from October served by aircraft based elsewhere. Staff are offered transfers to other European locations.Seven aircraft reassigned to other Ryanair centres13 aircraft already withdrawn from Frankfurt, Düsseldorf and Stuttgart basesGerman trade union Verdi condemns the move as profit‑drivenFinancial Ripple: Passenger Cuts and Aircraft RelocationThe reduction translates to a loss of roughly 2.3 million passengers per year. Combined with the doubling of jet‑fuel prices, the airline faces higher operating costs. American Airlines warned of a $4 billion hit this year from fuel price spikes, underscoring industry pressure.Broader Implications for German Aviation and European RailUnion leader Dennis Dacke argues Ryanair treats employees as “disposable commodities”. Environmental groups and rail advocates see an opening: Berlin’s rail links to Amsterdam, Warsaw, Prague, Vienna, Paris and a new Copenhagen service could attract displaced flyers.Potential increase in rail passenger volume to BerlinPressure on German airports to revisit tax and fee structuresRisk of reduced connectivity affecting trade and tourismOutlook: Ryanair’s Next Moves and German ConnectivityRyanair’s boss Michael O’Leary warned that up to 10 % of late‑summer flights could be cancelled if fuel shortages persist. The airline may focus on more tax‑friendly hubs while German policymakers face pressure to reform aviation taxes to retain low‑cost carriers.

The LeadGaza stands at a critical juncture as fragile ceasefires take hold between the United States and Iran, and between Israel and Lebanon. Palestinians in the enclave are questioning whether this regional de-escalation will allow Israel to intensify its military assaults in Gaza or force it toward a more cautious path. With more than 2,500 people killed in Lebanon and over a million displaced since March, and tensions still simmering in the Strait of Hormuz, the focus now shifts to what lies ahead for Gaza.Regional Ceasefires and Their ImplicationsSince April 8, the US and Iran have maintained a tense ceasefire after weeks of reciprocal strikes. Meanwhile, Israel and Lebanon have extended their ceasefire by three weeks, with US President Donald Trump announcing the agreement reached at the White House. These talks, however, excluded Hezbollah—the Iran-backed group that is a key Palestinian ally in the region. Despite the ceasefire, Israeli forces have established a "Yellow Line" demarcating occupied territory in southern Lebanon, mirroring tactics used in Gaza.The Israeli government has indicated its readiness to continue military operations in Gaza amid this relative calm on other fronts, raising fears among Palestinians of an all-out war returning to haunt them. This has created a complex geopolitical landscape where reduced tensions on some fronts may increase pressure on others.Two Scenarios for Gaza's FuturePalestinians in Gaza have identified two main scenarios emerging from the current situation. The first possibility is that the calm on the Iranian and Lebanese fronts leads Israel to put more military pressure on Gaza. The second scenario suggests that regional and global factors could prevent Israel from resuming full-scale military operations.Analysts Wissam Afifa and Ahed Farwana offer contrasting perspectives. Afifa believes the relative calm on other fronts increases Gaza's weight in Israeli calculations, allowing for "refocusing military and political attention on an unresolved agenda." However, he clarifies this doesn't necessarily mean a full-scale war but could lead to "intensified low-intensity political and security pressures."Farwana, meanwhile, argues that the pause in wars in Lebanon and Iran has reshuffled priorities within Israel, making Gaza "secondary" in the global discourse despite ongoing military operations. He suggests that an Israeli army exhausted from multiple wars, combined with manpower shortages, makes a return to full-scale war unlikely, with limited escalation being a more probable scenario.The Hamas Disarmament DilemmaA central obstacle in the US-backed Israel-Hamas "ceasefire" negotiations is the question of Hamas disarmament. The second phase of the agreement includes the formation of a national committee to govern Gaza, possible deployment of international forces, and talks on the future of weapons inside the enclave.Afifa describes Hamas's position of linking disarmament to a complete Israeli withdrawal and establishment of a Palestinian state as a "fundamentally strategic move, not merely a negotiating detail." Hamas wants discussions about its weapons to follow a full Israeli withdrawal, opening of border crossings, and Gaza's reconstruction—conditions laid out in the first phase of the ceasefire.Hamas spokesman Hazem Qassem criticized linking implementation to disarmament, calling it "a clear bias towards the Israeli perspective." He emphasized that Israel must "fulfil the terms of the Gaza ceasefire and implement first-phase commitments," noting that the blockade and killings continue with more than 700 deaths recorded since the start of the truce.Israeli Expansionist PoliciesQassem warned that Israel has not halted its military policies but rather "distributed them across multiple fronts." He described the situation in Gaza as a "massacre in these sense" as rodents swarm displacement camps and diseases spread, with Israel allowing less than a third of the agreed aid to enter.The threats extend beyond Gaza to the occupied West Bank, where settlers engage in violence and expand illegal settlements, and to Lebanon and Syria, posing risks to broader Arab security. Qassem attributed these actions to "aggressive and expansionist Israeli policies" led by a far-right government.Several rounds of talks between a Hamas delegation and UN envoy Nikolay Mladenov in Cairo have focused on stabilizing the ceasefire and ensuring implementation of its first phase, but have not yielded breakthroughs on sensitive issues like disarming Hamas.Regional and International PressuresAfifa identified a "balancing factor": The international community, particularly the US, may prefer to prevent a new conflagration in Gaza after pauses in fighting in Lebanon and Iran. He expects the Trump administration to apply the same approach in Gaza, focusing on "preventing a major explosion, buying time and pushing parties towards interim arrangements."However, Gaza presents a different case for Washington, which "links political and security progress to the issue of Hamas's weapons and governance arrangements" in the enclave, making the chances of US pressure on Israel more complex.Farwana emphasized that Gaza needs stronger engagement from Arab and Muslim nations to ensure peace and push toward implementation of the ceasefire's second phase. "US President Donald Trump is the only party capable of exerting real pressure on Netanyahu, as seen in Lebanon, but this depends on parallel Arab and Islamic pressure," he concluded.

The Lead: Playoff Confrontation and Historic PerformanceNikola Jokić and Julius Randle were ejected after Jaden McDaniels made a provocative layup with 2.1 seconds remaining in the Minnesota Timberwolves' 112-96 victory over the Denver Nuggets on Saturday night. The meaningless basket sparked a confrontation that overshadowed Ayo Dosunmu's historic 43-point performance, which marked the highest-scoring playoff game by a reserve in 50 years.The Provocative Layup and AftermathWith Minnesota already assured of victory, McDaniels chose to make the layup rather than run out the clock, a decision that infuriated Jokić. The 6ft 11in, 284lbs center jogged down from half-court to confront McDaniels, leading to a shoving match that resulted in ejections for both Jokić and Randle."I don't regret it," Jokić said of his actions. "Because he scored after everybody stopped playing."McDaniels had already drawn the ire of the Nuggets earlier in the series by calling Jokić and his teammates "bad defenders." Nuggets coach David Adelman criticized the decision to score, stating: "In 2026, that stuff just doesn't happen anymore. That's something that happens in the '80s, where teams would continue to score. But that's who he is."Historic Performance by DosunmuWhile the confrontation drew attention, Ayo Dosunmu delivered a performance for the ages, stepping up with injuries to Anthony Edwards and Donte DiVincenzo. Dosunmu scored 43 points, making 13 of 17 shots, including 5 of 5 from three-point range, and all 12 of his free throws in 42 minutes."Ayo was just out of this world, man," Timberwolves coach Chris Finch said. "Just play after play after play."The performance was the best by a substitute since Fred Brown scored 45 off the bench for Seattle in 1976. Dosunmu, who Minnesota acquired from Chicago in February, has emerged as a critical player in the series with Edwards and DiVincenzo sidelined.Series Implications and Injury ConcernsThe Timberwolves now lead the series 3-1 and can close it out in Game 5 on Monday night in Denver. "I expect us to have a great effort in Game 5," Nuggets coach David Adelman said. "I really trust our two best players will find a rhythm, and they have to find that at home."Jamal Murray led Denver with 30 points, while Jokić added 24 points, 15 rebounds and nine assists before his ejection. The Nuggets struggled from beyond the arc, making just 6 of 27 three-point attempts.For Minnesota, the injuries to Edwards and DiVincenzo remain significant concerns. Edwards, a four-time All-Star and the team's top scorer, left in the second quarter with a knee injury. DiVincenzo may have ruptured his Achilles tendon after exiting earlier in the game.Playoff Picture Across the LeagueIn other playoff action, Shai Gilgeous-Alexander scored a playoff-career-high 42 points to lift Oklahoma City to a 3-0 series lead over Phoenix. Karl Anthony-Towns recorded his first career playoff triple-double with 20 points, 10 assists and 10 rebounds as New York evened their series with Atlanta at 2-2. The Detroit Pistons fell to 2-1 against Orlando after Paolo Banchero and Desmond Bane each scored 25 points in the Magic's 113-105 victory.

The Historic Two-Hour Barrier Broken They call Sabastian Sawe the silent assassin. But it was impossible to ignore the beautiful destruction on the streets of London as the 30-year-old Kenyan became the first athlete to shatter the two-hour barrier in an official race. As Sawe crossed the line on the Mall, the clock showed that he had run 26.2 miles in a staggering 1 hour, 59mins and 30 seconds – 65 seconds faster than the previous best set by Kelvin Kiptum in 2023. The Record-Shattering Performance The world record had not just been destroyed. It had been obliterated. He came. He Sawe. He conquered. "I am feeling good, I am so happy," said Sawe. "It is a day to remember." Sawe's team had insisted their man was in shape, and that he would be helped by wearing the latest pair of Adidas Adios Pro 3 supershoes, which weigh in at just 97 grams – lighter than a baby kitten – and will retail for about £450. But no one expected this. Unprecedented Competition Not long behind him was Ethiopia's Yomif Kejelcha, who was 11 seconds back in his debut marathon. His time would have also shattered the world record. Uganda's Jacob Kiplimo, who came third in 2:00:28, was also inside it too. "I think today, it shows me a lot," Sawe told BBC Sport afterwards. "There is time for everyone. I think I was well-prepared because coming to London for the second time was so important to me." The Science Behind the Speed For the elite racers, the weather at the start was almost perfect for fast times: 11 degrees Celsius, sunny, and with a gentle tailwind over the crucial last few miles. And six men – including the favourites, Sawe and Kiplimo – were determined to take advantage. They hit the 10km mark, just before Cutty Sark, in 28 mins and 25 sec, a shade under world-record pace, and were through halfway in 60:29 secs, 12 seconds down. The Final Push to Glory At this point the men's race looked like being fast but not record-breaking. When the last pacemaker dropped out, though, Sawe and Kejelcha suddenly charged clear at a drinks station, surprising Kiplimo who found himself unable to fight back. By now they were pouring the pace on. Between 30-35km they ran an astonishing 13:54 5km. To put into context, the time is just 12 seconds slower than the world record for a 5km parkrun, set by the Irish international runner Nick Griggs. The Doping Question Addressed Naturally there will be questions about whether we can trust Sawe's record, given the chequered history of Kenyans failing doping tests in recent years. It should be noted, however, that before the Berlin marathon in September, Sawe's sponsors, Adidas, paid the Athletics Integrity Unit £50,000 to test him as many times as possible because they wanted to show he was clean. Not only was Sawe tested 25 times in a few weeks, but his samples were also scrutinised with top-end analysis, including isotope ratio mass spectrometry testing, which is much better at detecting tiny levels of banned drugs. The Women's Race Record The women's race turned into a three-way sprint down the Mall, with the Ethiopian Tigst Assefa defending her title after kicking from home in sight of Buckingham Palace. Her time of 2:15:41 was a women's only-word world record, which applies to races with only women's pace makers but is nearly five minutes slower than the official women's world record. In second place, 12 seconds back, was Kenya's Hellen Obiri, while her compatriot Joyciline Jepkosgei finished third. The Future of Marathon Running Sawe's achievement marks a new era in marathon running, pushing the boundaries of what was once considered humanly possible. With advancements in training techniques, equipment technology, and increasingly sophisticated doping detection methods, we can expect more records to fall in the coming years. The two-hour barrier, once thought to be an insurmountable milestone, has now been officially conquered, opening the door for even more ambitious targets in the sport.

The Lead: A Devilish Road Trip on StageChristopher Brett Bailey takes the audience on a night‑marish highway ride, confronting the devil in a stripped‑down Soho Theatre setting. The piece, a live reading of his 2023 novella, is framed as an adult‑bedtime story that oscillates between grotesque horror and surprising sweetness.The Devilish Narrative Unfolds: Minimalism Meets Surreal ViolenceThe performance contains no music or elaborate set; instead, Bailey reads from a table, using vocal tricks—slurps, hisses, whispers—to paint a vivid picture of “small‑town America, two miles north of hell.” The devil is portrayed as a bloated‑ego conspiracy nut, turning the road‑trip into a series of macabre vignettes.Costume: fringed leather jacket, snakeskin boots, electrified hair.Lighting: Alex Fernandes’s red wash that “reddens his skin.”Run time: exceeds the scripted length by roughly 15 minutes.The Audience Reaction: Length, Tone, and the Sweet‑Spot of ShockWhile the script runs over, the audience remains engaged, drawn in by Bailey’s “wide‑eyed glare” and the shifting tonal palette—from extreme vice to erotic tension. Critics note the piece feels more like an “adult bedtime story” than a conventional theatrical feat, yet its strangeness makes it memorable.The Cultural Resonance: Why This Matters for Experimental TheatreBailey’s work pushes the boundaries of what a stage reading can achieve, blurring lines between literature, performance art and horror cinema. By stripping away conventional production elements, the piece foregrounds voice and imagination, offering a template for low‑budget, high‑impact theatre in post‑pandemic London.The Road Ahead: Future Directions for Bailey and the Soho SceneIf the current run continues until 2 May, the show may tighten its pacing, potentially trimming the excess minutes that currently “sharpen throughout the run.” Success could encourage more venues to program similarly daring, minimalist works, expanding the appetite for avant‑garde storytelling in mainstream spaces.

The LeadThe bitter rivalry between two of the tech world's most powerful men arrives in court this week, as Elon Musk's lawsuit against Sam Altman and OpenAI heads to trial in Oakland, California. The case is set to feature some of the biggest names in Silicon Valley, and its outcome could affect the course of the AI boom.The Event DetailsMusk's suit, filed in 2024, focuses on the formative years of OpenAI when he, Altman and others co-founded the artificial intelligence company as a nonprofit with a grand purpose. The company's original mission statement declared: "OpenAI is a non-profit artificial intelligence research company. Our goal is to advance digital intelligence in the way that is most likely to benefit humanity as a whole, unconstrained by a need to generate financial return."Musk alleges that Altman, OpenAI's CEO, broke the company's founding agreement by restructuring the company and converting much of it to a for-profit enterprise. Altman and OpenAI counter that Musk, who left the firm in 2018 amid internal disputes and has since started his own rival AI business, is essentially a sore loser.The Data AnalysisThe case carries sizable stakes for OpenAI, which is expected to go public later this year at about a $1tn valuation. Musk is seeking a range of remedies that include the removal of Altman and OpenAI president Greg Brockman and more than $134bn in damages, which Musk says would be redistributed to OpenAI's non-profit arm.Jury selection in the trial starts on Monday at a federal courthouse in Oakland, with Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers overseeing the proceedings. The trial is expected to last two to three weeks.The Impact AnalysisWhile the central disagreement may concern convoluted corporate structures and contractual agreements, the trial itself promises to be an explosive high point in the feud between the two tech billionaires. Court filings featuring emails, texts and diary entries involving Musk and Altman have already hinted at dramatic episodes in OpenAI's history that will be detailed in full, and are rife with personal animosities and professional disputes that have shaped the AI industry.The case also represents a critical moment for the AI industry, as it could set precedents for how AI companies are structured and governed, particularly those that begin with nonprofit missions but later transition to for-profit models.The PredictionRegardless of the trial's outcome, the public airing of this dispute is likely to have lasting effects on both Musk's and Altman's reputations in the tech industry. The trial may also influence how future AI companies are structured and funded, with potential investors becoming more cautious about supporting organizations that transition from nonprofit to for-profit models.The case could also accelerate the development of regulatory frameworks for AI development and deployment, as the high-profile nature of this dispute draws increased attention from policymakers and regulators concerned with the governance of powerful AI systems.

The Unseen Threat: Landmine Crisis Persists in Post-Truce YemenDespite a ceasefire agreement in April 2022 that largely stopped fighting between Yemen's government and Houthi forces, the country continues to face a deadly crisis from landmines and explosive remnants of war. These hidden "sleeping killers" have turned fields, roads, and villages into areas of ongoing danger, claiming the lives and limbs of civilians, particularly children, long after the formal cessation of hostilities.Personal Stories of Loss and SurvivalIn August 2023, 13-year-old Enaya Dastor was tending to her goats near her village in central Yemen's Taiz governorate when she stepped on a landmine. The explosion resulted in the amputation of her left leg, leaving her with a lifelong disability. "Landmines are sleeping killers, waiting for the innocents to step on them or move them without caution. That is how they wake up to shed blood and take human souls," Dastor told Al Jazeera.Similarly, Mohammed Mustafa lost his left leg in a landmine explosion in Taiz's Maqbna district in 2018 when he was just 20 years old. After a five-hour ambulance ride to reach medical care, he awoke in the hospital to find his leg amputated up to the knee. Despite his injuries, Mustafa has rebuilt his life as a member of the Yemeni Amputee Football Federation, a father, and a small business owner.Alarming Statistics of Child VictimsThe scale of the landmine crisis is particularly devastating for Yemen's youngest population. According to Save the Children, landmines and explosive remnants of war have killed at least 339 children and injured 843 since the 2022 truce. The organization found that nearly half of child casualties related to the conflict were due to these hidden explosives.A 2022 study by Yemeni human rights groups revealed that 534 children and 177 women were killed by mines between April 2014 and March 2022. Additionally, 854 children, 255 women, and 147 elderly people were injured during the same period across 17 Yemeni provinces, with Taiz recording the highest number of incidents. In the first half of 2025 alone, 107 civilians were killed or injured, most of them children, including five who died while playing football on a dirt field in Taiz.De-mining Efforts Face Significant ObstaclesDespite ongoing de-mining efforts, Yemen faces numerous challenges in addressing the landmine crisis. Project Masam, a de-mining team funded by Saudi Arabia, reported removing 549,452 mines, unexploded ordnance, and improvised explosive devices by March 2026, clearing explosives from 7,799 hectares of land. The Danish Refugee Council has cleared more than 23,302 square meters of Yemeni land from mines and explosive remnants.However, Adel Dashela, a Yemeni researcher focusing on conflict and peace building studies, highlights several obstacles to effective de-mining: "The mines have been planted indiscriminately in different areas, and some of the territories are under the control of different armed groups, which makes them inaccessible to de-miners." Other challenges include the lack of clear maps, shortage of qualified local personnel, and insufficient modern equipment for detecting explosives. Additionally, natural phenomena like the flash floods Yemen experienced in August 2025 can sweep explosives from one area to another, complicating clearance efforts and exposing more people to risk.Humanitarian Crisis Without ResolutionThe persistence of landmines in Yemen represents a complex humanitarian crisis that extends beyond the physical dangers they pose. The presence of these explosives prevents displaced families from returning to their homes, disrupts agricultural activities, and hinders economic recovery in affected areas. For many survivors like Enaya Dastor, the physical injury is accompanied by the loss of home and community, as her family was forced to flee their village and has not returned since the explosion.The landmine crisis also reflects the broader challenges of post-conflict recovery in Yemen, where no final peace agreement has been reached to end the war that began in 2014. Without a comprehensive political solution, the country remains divided, making coordinated de-mining efforts and long-term recovery planning extremely difficult.Hope Amidst Crisis: Survivors Determined to RebuildDespite the devastating impact of landmines on their lives, many Yemeni survivors demonstrate remarkable resilience and determination to rebuild their futures. Enaya Dastor, who lost her leg at age 13, remains focused on her education and aspirations: "Today, I am in tenth grade, and I will finish high school in two years. After that, I will enrol in law college and will graduate as a lawyer. I want to defend those who face injustice.""The injury has changed how I move or walk, and separated my family from our home," Dastor said. "But it cannot disable my mind or stop my dreams." Her determination, along with the efforts of de-mining organizations and the international community, offers a glimmer of hope for Yemen's future, though the path to a mine-free country remains long and uncertain.