Breaking AI & Tech News Analyzed

The Lead: International Outrage Over Ben-Gvir's Video Israel's far-right National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir has posted a video of himself taunting foreign activists abducted from a Gaza-bound aid flotilla at a makeshift holding pen in Israel's city of Ashdod. The activists, abducted by Israeli forces in international waters, are seen cable-tied and kneeling while Israel's national anthem blares in the video, which was released on Wednesday. Several countries, including Italy and France, have summoned Israeli ambassadors to explain the stunt. As well as a global backlash, the video has even been met with sharp rebukes from Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and staunch ally, United States ambassador to Israel, Mike Huckabee. Who is Ben-Gvir: The Far-Right Minister at the Center of Controversy The 50-year-old lawyer and politician has led the far-right Jewish Power (Otzma Yehudit) party in Israel since 2019. He was sworn into the cabinet after the 2022 elections and was later appointed as national security minister and given control of Israel's Border Police division in the occupied West Bank. A settler in Kiryat Arba, one of the most radical settlements on Palestinian land in the occupied West Bank – all of which are illegal under international law – Ben-Gvir has convictions for incitement to racism, destroying property, possessing a "terror" organisation's propaganda material and supporting a "terror" organisation – Meir Kahane's outlawed Kach group, whose founder advocated for expelling non-Jews from Israel and which Ben-Gvir joined when he was 16. He frequently carries out anti-Palestinian acts, including regularly storming the Al-Aqsa Mosque compound in occupied East Jerusalem's Old City, Islam's third holiest site, alongside Israeli settlers and under the protection of Israeli forces. The Flotilla Activists: International Aid Efforts to Gaza This refers primarily to the Gaza aid flotillas – groups of boats carrying activists from different countries which have set out across the Mediterranean in an attempt to deliver aid and raise awareness at various times since October 2023, when Israel launched its brutal assault on the Gaza Strip, which has killed more than 72,000 Palestinians, mostly civilians. The modern flotilla movement emerged in 2006 during Israel's war on Lebanon and expanded after Israel imposed its blockade on Gaza in 2007. Since then, hundreds of vessels organised by international solidarity groups have attempted to reach the territory, carrying humanitarian aid and activists. In 2008, two boats from the Free Gaza Movement became the first to successfully reach Gaza by sea despite the blockade. But since 2010, Israeli forces have intercepted nearly every flotilla in international waters. On Tuesday, at least 430 activists from more than 46 countries were abducted during Israeli interceptions of the latest flotilla. The Video: Ben-Gvir's Taunting of Detained Activists In the video released on Wednesday, a woman approaches the minister and says in English, "Free Palestine!" before masked security officers put their hands on her head as they snap it down and push her away. "Good job," Ben-Gvir says to the officers, before stating, "Welcome to Israel. We are the landowners here; that is how it should be." Activists are then seen on their knees with their heads on the ground and arms tied behind their backs in "stress positions" as the figures of armed Israeli security officers look down on them from atop shipping containers. Ben-Gvir, waving an Israeli flag and heavily protected by security personnel, can be seen weaving in between the activists, appearing to relish the moment as he taunts them. International Response: Global Condemnation of Israel's Actions Several countries, including Italy, France, the Netherlands and Canada, have summoned Israeli ambassadors to their capitals to express their "indignation" over Israel's treatment of the abducted Gaza flotilla activists and to demand the release of their citizens. French Foreign Minister Jean-Noel Barrot also denounced Ben-Gvir's actions as "unacceptable", calling for the release of French citizens "as soon as possible". Canadian Foreign Minister Anita Anand called the incident "deeply troubling". United Kingdom Foreign Secretary Yvette Cooper said the video showed "totally disgraceful scenes". "The images of Israeli Minister Ben Gvir are unacceptable. It is unacceptable that these protesters, including many Italian citizens, are subjected to this treatment that violates their human dignity," Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni said in a statement on X. Previous Treatment of Activists: A Pattern of Controversy In May 2010, when Israeli commandos stormed the Turkish ship Mavi Marmara, 10 activists were killed and dozens were wounded. Allegations of mistreatment by activists who have been brought to Israel after naval interceptions have been common, and organisers say they fear sanctions and accusations of Hamas links are being used to justify further crackdowns. The concerns come amid previous allegations by activists of abuse, including sexual abuse, during past interceptions by Israeli officials. Organisers have also accused Israeli naval forces of firing "rubber bullets" at activists during the latest interception, which occurred in international waters. Many activists who have previously been detained have been eager to point out that the focus should be on Palestinian prisoners in Israeli jails who are subjected to torture and do not have the option to be deported. In 2025, high-profile activist Greta Thunberg, who was on board a previous flotilla, told Swedish newspaper Aftonbladet that activists had been beaten, kicked and threatened with being gassed in cages. Palestinian Prisoners: The Broader Context of Detention Nearly 10,000 Palestinians are currently being held in Israeli prisons in Israel and in the occupied territory, according to the prisoners' rights group Addameer. Some 3,532 of them are administrative detainees – people held without charge or trial – while 342 are children. Israel is the only country in the world that tries children in military courts, often denying them their basic rights. Palestinians detained in Israeli prisons suffer near-constant dehumanising treatment by guards and soldiers. Under a new law passed this year and spearheaded by Ben-Gvir, military courts are now able to impose the death penalty on Palestinians convicted of killing Israelis in acts of "terror". This law will not impose the same penalty on Jewish Israelis convicted of killing Palestinians, which reinforces the legal inequalities that grant privileges to Jewish citizens while targeting Palestinians.

The Rise in Lyme Disease Cases Cases of Lyme disease have risen more than 20% in England in the past year, public health experts have revealed, as pharmaceutical companies work to create new vaccines and drugs to tackle the tick-borne illness. Lyme Disease Statistics According to data from the UK Health Security Agency (UKHSA), published as part of its One Health vector-borne disease surveillance report, there were 1,168 laboratory-confirmed cases of Lyme disease in 2025, up from 959 in 2024 – an increase of 22%. However, the figure is similar to that recorded in 2023, when there were 1,151 confirmed cases. The Impact of Lyme Disease Lyme disease is caused by a type of bacteria called Borrelia burgdorferi, which lives in the gut of ticks – tiny spider-like creatures found in grassy and wooded areas that feed on the blood of birds and mammals, including humans. Symptoms of Lyme can include a bullseye-like rash, fever, muscle and joint pain, and lethargy. Left untreated, the condition can become chronic and, even among those who receive antibiotics, some report ongoing symptoms. New Treatments and Vaccines Several new treatments are in the works, including an mRNA vaccine from Moderna – a jab that is in phase 2 of its clinical development – as well as a different vaccine from Pfizer and Valneva. The Future Outlook While the number of laboratory-confirmed acute cases of Lyme disease in 2025 is an increase on numbers reported in 2024, experts expect overall case rates to vary year to year depending on awareness, testing rates, and factors that impact outdoor activities such as weather. Broader trends in 2025 remain consistent, with an increasing geographical distribution of ticks across the UK.

The WHO World Health Assembly Spotlights a Growing Mental‑Health CrisisThe World Health Organization (WHO) convened in Geneva for its 79th World Health Assembly, placing mental health among over 75 agenda items. With >1 billion people—roughly one in eight worldwide—living with a mental condition, the assembly serves as a pivotal forum for scaling up services and funding.Key Prevalence Figures and Disorder ClassificationsWHO and DSM‑5 categorize mental disorders into mood, anxiety, psychotic, trauma‑related, and other groups. The most common disorders globally are:Depressive disorders: 694.6 per 100,000Anxiety disorders: 686.5 per 100,000Schizophrenia: 210.2 per 100,000Bipolar disorder: 94.6 per 100,000Eating disorders: 47.5 per 100,000Financial Landscape: Spending Gaps Across Income LevelsMedian government spending on mental health is only 2 % of total health budgets. Per‑capita spending varies dramatically:Low‑income countries: $0.04Lower‑middle‑income countries: $0.34High‑income countries: $65.89Regional Prevalence and the Suicide Epidemic2019 WHO data show the following regional prevalence rates:Americas: 15.6 %Eastern Mediterranean: 14.7 %Europe: 14.2 %Southeast Asia: 13.2 %Western Pacific: 11.7 %Africa: 10.9 %Suicide accounts for 740,000 deaths annually—one every 43 seconds. It ranks 17th among all causes of death, but is the 3rd leading cause for ages 15‑29 and 2nd for women 15‑29. Male suicide rates (12.8/100,000) are four times higher than female rates (5.4/100,000).Why the Numbers Matter: Policy, Equity, and Public Health ImplicationsThe data reveal three urgent challenges:Under‑funding: With only 2 % of health budgets allocated, many low‑ and middle‑income countries lack basic treatment infrastructure.Gender and age disparities: Women face higher anxiety and depression rates; young people bear a disproportionate suicide burden.Vulnerable populations: Refugees, Indigenous peoples, and LGBTQ+ communities experience elevated suicide risk.Addressing these gaps requires coordinated investment, culturally competent services, and targeted prevention programs.Looking Ahead: Scaling Up Treatment and Closing the Funding GapIf current trends continue, prevalence will keep rising, especially for anxiety disorders, which have grown >50 % since 1990. Experts predict that doubling global mental‑health spending to at least 4 % of health budgets could halve the treatment gap within a decade, reduce suicide rates, and improve overall productivity. The upcoming WHO resolutions aim to set measurable targets for service expansion, data collection, and cross‑sector collaboration.

The Lead: Worker Exploitation in Aramco's Supply ChainA report by human rights group FairSquare has revealed that migrant workers in Saudi Aramco's supply chain face serious safety risks and exploitation, with difficulties in claiming compensation after injuries. The findings highlight a stark contrast between Aramco's status as one of the world's most profitable companies and the treatment of workers in its extensive contractor network.The Worker's Story: Shrawan Shah Rauniyar's OrdealShrawan Shah Rauniyar, a Nepalese migrant worker, lies in a hospital bed in Saudi Arabia with his legs encased in plaster casts after being crushed under a metal beam that fell off a forklift. Despite working on a project for Saudi Aramco—one of the most profitable companies in the world—Rauniyar was not employed directly by the state-owned energy company but by a small labor supply company.When staff from Saipem (the Italian firm contracted to Aramco) visited him in hospital, they brought flowers and chocolates but delivered a blunt message: "Don't ask us about compensation. We don't know about it. You're a contract worker for us. Talk to your employer." Rauniyar alleges that men from his labor supply company later threatened him in hospital, telling him to "Go home. Otherwise, we'll kill you. We'll kick you out on the street."Less than three weeks after the accident, Rauniyar claims staff from the labor supply company "forcefully" took him to the airport and put him on a plane back to Nepal without receiving the compensation he was entitled to under his contract and Saudi law.The Report's Findings: Systemic Labor Rights AbusesFairSquare's report documents 23 cases of alleged labor rights abuses among workers employed by Aramco's contractors and subcontractors in Saudi Arabia. The report finds that migrant workers in Aramco's supply chain "are exposed to serious safety and health risks, and face significant challenges in claiming compensation in the event of injury or death."Workers interviewed by FairSquare alleged they endured grave labor rights violations, including:Exposure to extreme heatWork shifts of up to 19 hoursBeing put up in what the rights group calls "slum housing"Being paid just 1,000 rials (£200) per month for 10-hour shiftsDeductions from wages for taking days offOvercrowded living conditions with "rotten" foodThe Corporate Giant: Aramco's Scale and InfluenceThe findings are particularly striking given that Aramco is one of the wealthiest, most profitable and influential corporations in the world. As Saudi Arabia's national oil company, it provides about two-thirds of the government's revenue. It is the fourth largest company in the world by revenue, with a market value of about $1.7tn (£1.3tn) – roughly the same as the next five energy companies combined.Aramco employs more than 76,000 people, but this figure hides a far larger number of workers employed through a long and complex chain of thousands of contractors and subcontractors. These workers, who are overwhelmingly migrant laborers from South Asia, do the often difficult and dangerous work that drives Aramco's profits, from constructing its facilities to transporting its petrol.The Global Brand: Aramco's World Cup ConnectionAramco is not just the economic engine of Saudi Arabia but also plays a leading role in the kingdom's efforts to rebrand itself on the global stage, notably through sports. As one of Fifa's main sponsors, its name will be plastered all over the World Cup. However, severe labor violations were uncovered at Aramco Stadium, the first new venue to be developed for the 2034 football World Cup.Earlier this year, it was reported that the family of a Pakistani worker who fell to his death at the stadium was still waiting for compensation almost a year after his death. This case, along with others documented in FairSquare's report, raises questions about Aramco's commitment to worker safety and rights despite its high-profile global partnerships.The Legal Framework: Corporate and Government ResponsibilitiesSuch an extensive labour supply chain does not exempt Aramco from its responsibilities to its entire workforce. The UN's Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights require companies to prevent human rights abuses "throughout their operations". Aramco appears to accept this, stating online: "Aramco is committed to supporting and empowering our workforce and the communities where we operate. The safety and wellbeing of our employees, their dependents, and our company's contractors is paramount to our strategy and operations."As a majority state-owned company, the UN's guiding principles put additional responsibilities on the Saudi government "to ensure that relevant policies, legislation and regulations regarding respect for human rights are implemented". However, the findings suggest that these principles are not being effectively enforced in practice.The Aftermath: Life After InjuryNow back in Nepal, Rauniyar is confined to a small room he rents. Doctors have told him the bones in his right leg have not joined properly and he may need further surgery, but he says he does not have the money for it. "My legs hurt when I walk. I can't lift weights. If my legs hadn't been broken, I could have worked somewhere, but not in this condition," he says.Even before the accident, Rauniyar was struggling in Saudi Arabia. He claims he was housed in overcrowded rooms "like pigs", and his fellow workers fell sick because of the "rotten" food. Now he relies on his wife's meagre teaching salary of 7000 rupees (£35) a month and some fees from tuition classes he runs for local children. "We are poor. I don't have a home. I don't have anything. My life has collapsed," he says.The Compensation Crisis: Broken PromisesUnder Saudi law, when a worker is injured or dies in the course of their job, they or their family should receive compensation from a government insurance scheme or directly from their employer. Yet compensation was only paid out in one of the six cases of injury or death documented in FairSquare's report.FairSquare's findings are consistent with reports from Human Rights Watch and the Business and Human Rights Resource Centre, which last year found evidence of rights abuses in Aramco's labour supply chain. These repeated findings suggest a systemic issue that goes beyond isolated incidents.The Industry Impact: Reputational Risks and AccountabilityThe revelations about labor conditions in Aramco's supply chain come at a time when multinational corporations face increasing scrutiny over their human rights records. As Aramco continues to expand its global partnerships and sponsorships, including high-profile sporting events like the World Cup, these findings pose significant reputational risks.The case also highlights the challenges of enforcing labor rights in complex supply chains, where responsibility is often diffused across multiple layers of contractors and subcontractors. This creates a situation where workers fall through the cracks, with no clear entity held accountable for their welfare.The Future Outlook: Calls for Reform and AccountabilityFairSquare's director, Nick McGeehan, stated: "Aramco obviously has a responsibility to protect these workers, but it also has tremendous influence to set standards that flow down its supply chain to hundreds of thousands of workers across Saudi Arabia. The neglect that we see in its supply chain indicates that it takes migrant worker protection no more seriously than the Saudi state."As global attention focuses on Saudi Arabia's hosting of the World Cup and its broader Vision 2030 economic diversification plan, there are growing calls for Aramco to demonstrate genuine commitment to worker rights. The company faces the challenge of reconciling its public commitments to safety and wellbeing with the realities faced by workers in its supply chain.

Bezos Defends Amazon’s $40 Million Melania Documentary PurchaseIn a CNBC interview, Jeff Bezos described Amazon’s acquisition of the Melania Trump documentary as “a good business decision,” emphasizing that he had no personal role in the deal.Amazon’s Acquisition and Marketing Spend for the Melania FilmThe streaming giant bought the film for $40 million, with the former first lady reportedly receiving $28 million. Amazon allocated roughly $35 million for marketing the release.Director: Brett Ratner, previously accused of sexual misconduct.Release: January, without a press screening.Streaming performance: Listed among Amazon’s most‑watched titles, though exact viewership data remain undisclosed.Financial Snapshot: Costs, Revenues, and Box‑Office PerformanceThe documentary earned about $16.7 million worldwide, falling short of recouping its production budget.Total outlay (acquisition + marketing): $75 million.Box‑office gross: $16.7 million.Bezos’ assessment: Strong theatrical and streaming performance despite the shortfall.Political Fallout and Corporate Governance ConcernsSenator Elizabeth Warren criticized the deal as a possible “pay‑to‑play” arrangement with the Trump administration, citing anti‑bribery law exposure. Amazon denied any bribery, framing the film as having “cultural and historical relevance.”Accusation: Favorable treatment from the administration in exchange for a far‑above‑market payment.Amazon’s response: No bribery, emphasis on content value.Outlook for Amazon’s Content Strategy Amid ScrutinyBezos’ public defense signals confidence in Amazon’s media investments, but the political backlash may prompt tighter internal review of high‑profile acquisitions. Observers will watch whether future content deals balance commercial ambition with reputational risk.

Early‑stage evidence from a University of Bristol randomised controlled trial suggests that the anti‑inflammatory drug tocilizumab may improve symptoms in patients with moderate‑to‑severe depression who have not responded to standard antidepressants.Trial Overview: Testing Tocilizumab for Treatment‑Resistant DepressionThe study examined whether blocking the IL‑6R receptor could alleviate depressive symptoms. Key design elements:Participants: 30 adults with moderate‑to‑severe depression unresponsive to conventional medication.Intervention: Intravenous tocilizumab versus placebo.Duration: four‑week double‑blind period.Outcomes measured: depression severity, fatigue, state anxiety, and quality of life.Key Numbers: Sample Size, Remission Rates, and NNTAlthough the trial was not powered to reach statistical significance, observed trends were notable:Depression remission: 54% in the tocilizumab group vs 31% in the placebo group.Number Needed to Treat (NNT): 5, meaning five patients would need treatment for one additional remission.For comparison, the NNT for first‑line SSRIs is approximately 7.The lack of robust statistical proof reflects the small cohort, underscoring the need for larger studies.Potential Shift in Depression Treatment ParadigmsResearchers describe the trial as an “important milestone” because it is:One of the first randomised trials to test immunotherapy for depression.The inaugural study targeting the IL‑6R pathway in this context.A proof‑of‑concept for selecting patients based on biological markers.Given that up to one‑third of depressed patients do not improve with existing pharmacotherapies, a biologically driven approach could expand therapeutic options and move psychiatry toward more personalised care.What Comes Next: Larger Studies and Clinical ImplicationsThe investigators plan to:Conduct larger, multi‑centre trials to confirm efficacy and safety.Explore longer treatment durations and dosage optimisation.Assess whether IL‑6R blockade can be combined with existing antidepressants.If subsequent trials replicate these findings, immunotherapy could become a viable adjunct or alternative for treatment‑resistant depression, potentially reshaping clinical guidelines and drug development pipelines.

The Controversial Video Israeli National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir has published a video on social media platform X, taunting activists who were detained on a flotilla attempting to break the blockade on Gaza. The video, which has sparked widespread criticism, shows Ben-Gvir interacting with the detained activists, questioning their actions and motivations. Background on the Flotilla The flotilla, organized by a coalition of international groups, aimed to challenge Israel's maritime blockade on Gaza, which has been in place since 2007. The blockade, imposed by Israel and Egypt, restricts the movement of people and goods in and out of Gaza, leading to significant economic and humanitarian challenges for the region's population. International Reaction and Concerns Human rights organizations and activists have condemned Ben-Gvir's actions, citing concerns over the treatment and rights of the detained individuals. The incident has drawn international attention, with many calling for greater accountability and respect for human rights in the region. The Future of Israel-Palestine Relations This latest development is likely to further strain relations between Israel and Palestine, as well as exacerbate tensions within the international community. As the situation continues to unfold, there will be close scrutiny of Israel's actions and their implications for the region's stability and peace prospects.

The Growing Ebola Crisis in Central AfricaThe World Health Organization (WHO) has confirmed a significant increase in Ebola cases, reporting 600 suspected cases with 139 deaths in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) and Uganda. This outbreak, declared a public health emergency of international concern, has emerged just five months after the DRC's previous epidemic was declared over.The Emergency Response and Risk AssessmentDuring an Emergency Committee meeting in Geneva, WHO Director-General Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus confirmed that the virus remains a public health emergency of international concern, but not a pandemic emergency. "The WHO assess the risk of the epidemic as high at the national and regional levels and low at the global level," Tedros stated.WHO emergencies chief Chikwe Ihekweazu emphasized that the organization's "absolute priority now is to identify all the existing chains of transmission" to define the outbreak's scale and provide appropriate care.Rising Case Numbers and Geographic SpreadPrevious figures reported by DRC officials indicated 131 deaths from 513 suspected cases, showing a significant increase in both cases and fatalities. Of the 600 suspected cases, 51 have been confirmed in the DRC's northern provinces of Ituri and North Kivu.The outbreak has crossed borders, with Uganda confirming two cases in Kampala, including one death, from individuals who traveled from the DRC. A medical missionary who contracted Ebola in the DRC is also being transported to Germany for treatment.The Challenge of the Bundibugyo StrainHealth authorities have identified the Bundibugyo strain as the cause of this outbreak, a particularly concerning development as no vaccine or treatment currently exists for this variant of the Ebola virus. This strain was first identified in Uganda in 2007 and has caused previous outbreaks with high fatality rates.WHO experts believe the outbreak began a few months ago, with the first suspected death reported on April 20. Following this initial death, officials suspect a super-spreader event occurred at either a funeral or healthcare facility, though investigations are ongoing to confirm the exact circumstances.Regional and Global ImplicationsThe outbreak presents significant challenges for the already fragile healthcare systems in the DRC and neighboring Uganda. The declaration of a public health emergency of international concern mobilizes global resources and attention to contain the spread.On the global front, a European Union spokesperson has stated that the risk of an outbreak in Europe is "very low," emphasizing that while "diseases do not stop at the borders," there is no indication that Europeans need to take extraordinary measures beyond standard health advice.Path Forward in Containing the OutbreakWith the WHO's emergency declaration, international health organizations and local authorities are working to implement containment strategies. The focus remains on identifying transmission chains, providing care for those affected, and preventing further spread across borders.The situation remains fluid, with health officials closely monitoring developments in both affected countries. The international community's response will be crucial in determining whether this outbreak can be contained before it escalates further.

The Apology and Investigation Channel 4's chief executive, Priya Dogra, has stood by the broadcaster's treatment of concerns raised by contestants on Married at First Sight, as she said she was “deeply sorry” for the distress of female participants making allegations of rape and sexual misconduct. Dogra said she believed the channel had acted appropriately at the time of the allegations, but had commissioned an external review to ensure the show was safe for those taking part. Allegations and Concerns An edition of the BBC's Panorama aired allegations by two women that they were raped by their on-screen husbands on Married at First Sight (MAFS) UK. They have not been named. A third woman, who agreed to be identified, Shona Manderson, accused her on-screen husband of subjecting her to a non-consensual sex act. All the men deny the claims. The BBC has since been contacted by a number of former MAFS UK cast members raising concerns, according to its culture and media editor, Katie Razzall. Response from Authorities The Metropolitan police also reiterated its appeal to anyone with allegations of abuse during the show to come forward. They are already in touch with Channel 4 and CPL, the independent production company that makes the show for the broadcaster. “We are ready to listen to them,” said the Met assistant commissioner Matt Twist. “We are ready to investigate.” Future Actions and Review Speaking at Channel 4's annual report, Dogra said that while she believed the broadcaster had acted appropriately, she had ordered external reviews to take a “second look”, given she only took up her role in March. “I have watched the programme and heard the women's accounts, which are very troubling,” she said. “Their distress is clear, and for that I am, of course, deeply sorry. Ian Katz, Channel 4's chief content officer, said: “I am very confident that, based on the knowledge that we had at the time, that we made the right decisions, that we ensured that women involved were kept safe when any issues were raised to us, that we gave them the appropriate support – and that we took the right decisions through the production process and beyond that. “But obviously these are serious allegations, and it's clearly right to take a second look at them and make sure that we got it right at the time and more importantly to look at whether there's anything we need to learn about how to make the show in future.” Reaction from MPs MPs on the Commons culture select committee have now written to Channel 4 about its handling and to Ofcom about its involvement, as well as the timeline for launching its own investigation into the allegations. Caroline Dinenage, the Conservative chair of the committee, said: “The horrifying allegations about Married at First Sight raise serious concerns over whether enough is being done to protect people taking part in reality television. Both Channel 4 and Ofcom, as the broadcasting regulator, have urgent questions to answer.”